By P4 on March 20, 2003
Photo by Dine & Dish
Photo by Dine & Dish
"These cookies are absolutely delicious and absolutely addictive! I keep rolls of it on hand in the freezer and just slice off as many as I want to bake at one time. They never last long. My 2 year old LOVES them. Another winner from FC..."
Serving Size: 1 (1392 g)
Servings Per Recipe: 1
"Wow, these cookies are delicious! I followed the recipe exactly and the cookies baked up perfectly. I used walnuts (fresh from my tree) instead of pecans. For those of you who said the cookies spread too much - did you try chilling the dough before baking? If the butter/margarine/shortening is too soft when you add it, the cookies will spread more in the oven. Also, you should always make sure the cookie sheets have cooled before putting more cookie dough on them."
"YUM!!!! I doubled the salt and honey but otherwise kept it the same. Such a great texture!! I also soaked the raisins in some boiling water for 15 minutes before mixing in to keep them mega soft."
"Everything Petitfour says is true. These are delicious and truly addictive. I have made more batches of these this month than I can count. Some with cranberries, some with mixed dried fruits and some with tropical fruits and they were all delicious."
"Great recipe!! I added peanut butter as well...Will definitely use this in the future."
"I just made these and baked only 2 cookies to taste...they were sooo goood! I rolled up the rest into a log and put it in the freezer. I plan to bake it for my Girls' Luncheon in three days! Thanks for a great recipe!"
"I made these for the first time and they were really good!!! I decreased the sugar to 1/2 brown and 1/2 white; didn't have any parchment paper so I sprayed the cookie sheet with cooking spray and they came out perfect. Baked them exactly between 9-10 minutes, will be making them again definitely."
"I made this recipe yesterday and the cookies were delicious. I used parchment paper for the first time and I will never bake without it again. It is great! I wondered about the tbsp. of honey in this recipe but it must help with the golden brown color and great texture. I made about 42 cookies using a rounded tbsp. I didn't add cranberries due to my husband's insistence. The oven time was dead on and this will now be my official oatmeal cookie recipe. They were lovely and crisp on the outside and soft and chewy in the middle. How nice to find a recipe that needs no adjustments regarding oven time, etc. Thank you Petitfour!"
"Very tasty cookies and they looked great on my gift trays. I could only find orange flavored Craisins, so the flavor was a bit different, but still yummy. I also used walnuts instead of the pecans. Thanks for posting...I had these at a church bazaar and just had to search out the recipe...these tasted very similar, except not as many walnuts. Next time I will use regular Craisins and I think increase the nuts. Thanks again! Next time I will use regular Craisins and I think increase the nuts. P.S. I needed exactly 9 minutes bake time and got close to 5 dozen cookies."
"I gave made these several times and am now getting around to rating. These are absolutely delicious. Made these one year and brought some in to work and was subsequently asked to join the Bake Club, they were that good. I keep getting repeat requests from co-workers. I didn't have any honey, so made them without. I don't think the flavor suffered. Definately added as one of my favorite cookies."
"My daughter chose this recipe to bake for a 4-H cookie bake and won first place in her class. She now moves on to the county level. YEA! Thank you for sharing."
"My son's Cub Scout den was having an oatmeal cookie competition last night, so I came here to search for a good sounding recipe to make. Right out of the oven I could tell these were a winner. I had to have a taste, and let me tell you, they were so GOOD! They were soft and chewy. There were 11 different cookies in the competition, and this cookie won 1st place!! One of the judges was a professional chef, and she raved about the cookie and wanted the recipe! Thank you so much for sharing your award winning recipe!"
"Mmmmm delicious cookie. I made these and DD was leary because of the cranberries in it. Well, she loved them. We all did. thank you for sharing with slightly different version of a great oatmeal cookie."
"excellent recipe, best ever, just do it exactly as written"
"Great recipe, but I like a soft, not-so-flat cookie. After reading reviews about the cookies coming out flat, I decreased the butter to 5 tbsp (I halved this recipe). I also substituted almonds and baked the cookies at 325"
"Delicious! I added coconut and it was fabulous"
"I love oatmeal cookies, but never could seem to find a yummy AND chewy recipe. I found both in this recipe. It's a keeper! Thank you for submitting it!"
"Made these today for my husband, and he loved them.I would have liked them to he a bit more fluffy because after they cooled down they got a little flat due to the spreading they did in the over but other then that they are a big hit in my house."
"I don't see what all the 5 stars are about. The cookies turned out fine for me but nothing amazing, especially considering all the butter! I didn't have a bowl big enough for the recipe; I ended up separating it into two bowls in order to deal with all of it! Good but nothing special."
"Super easy and people loved it!!"
"Delish! I made with Splenda instead of white sugar. I also used almost 2 cups of fresh cranberries that I diced up. I didn't add nuts b/c I didn't have any. These were super yummy"