By Young Living in Texas on October 14, 2002
Photo by Marg (CaymanDesigns)
Photo by Marg (CaymanDesigns)
"This pie is so rich. It is so quick and easy. It is also enjoyed quick and easy. You must try this for your next Chocolate Pie. I HAVE to make it EVERY Thanksgiving, especially for son Kevin and son-in-law Dwain. My sister-in-law, Sherry, entered it in their 1996 church cookbook, "Give Us This Day Our Daily Bread", Wise County, Texas."
Serving Size: 1 (183 g)
Servings Per Recipe: 6
"The pie is very rich and not as sweet as I expected, it really doesn't need to be. It was pretty easy to make, I'm describing the thickening portion more as it isn't as clear as it could be here from other commentors. Generalities, as some people reported trouble thickening, I used 4 tbsp of corn starch instead of 3. I added a pinch of cinnamon to enhance the chocolate flavor. I do step 1 as directed. I start 2, add the condensed milk and start heating the filling on medium heat with the eggs off to the side (I use 2 lightly beaten eggs instead of fooling with egg yolks) stirring continuously. 3.) Once bubbly I set on the side and pour 1/4 of the mix into the dish with the eggs, I mix this till smooth. 4.) I return everything to the saucepan and return to heat. 5.) I added the vanilla and butter stirring continuously until bubbly again and is thick. 6.) Pour into pie shell 7.) Lay syran wrap over pie to prevent skin from forming and refridgerate. I topped with vanilla flavored sweet whipped cream."
"This is the classic Chocolate Cream Pie that you have been searching for. Consistency, depth of chocolate flavor and level of sweetness are perfect, probably as is, but per the many reviews that suggested it, I used 4 TBS of corn starch and 6 TBS of cocoa powder.
Used a chocolate cookie crust, and topped with homemade whipped cream.
Keep whisking whisking while it sets up during cooking and as it cools a bit before you put it in the crust.
It's so easy and was a huge huge hit with my family. Made it for Valentines day and again today.
Don't forget the plastic wrap, don't worry it won't stick.
This WILL become your CCP recipe! Thanks Peggy if you ever read here!"
"This isn't even in the crust yet but I know it's exactly what I had been looking for! The filling is awesome. I really wanted the simplest recipe where I didn't have to melt chocolate and this was perfect. I used Ghiradelli Cocoa Powder. I whisked the cocoa powder and cornstarch together and then whisked in about 1/2 c of cool water until a paste formed then gradually whisked in the rest of the water. I had no lumps by using this method. Actually just keeping the whisk moving keeps the filling smooth. I'm going to top with whipped cream since I'm not a meringue person. Absolutely a keeper! Thank you so much!"
"Very good, fast, easy and delicious. I cheated and used a graham cracker crust. Made it for my son's 4th grade pie day (3/14). It was a hit. He said that was the first pie to run out. I only tasted the filling, yum. As per the other reviewers, I increased the cocoa and corn starch by 1 tablespoon each. I also used two whole eggs instead of three yolks. I also used half boiling water to make it faster and easier to dissolve the starch and cocoa. Don't forget the plastic wrap over the pie to prevent the yukky dried up layer on top, it really won't stick. I served it with whipped cream and dark chocolate shavings as a garnish. Thank you and a bunch of 4th graders thank you."
"I made this pie last night and sad to say, it did not set! I had problems with my,store bought, pastry shredding also,I guess yesterday wasn't a good day to make a chocolate pie, even though, I had all the ingredients. All was not lost! I took that shredded, cooked, pie crust and soupy chocolate filling and added some blueberry flavored cream cheese. It created the most heavenly hash. Oh My Goodness, it was so delicious,more delicious than I could have ever imagined. I'm really not that adventurous,when it comes to food but this was off the hook! I'll admit,I did not follow the recipe exactly, because I added, sugar,that may have been the reason,the filling did not set. I will try the pie again,perhaps,add more cornstarch or cook it a little longer, next time. It really did taste good!"
"Very good and very easy to make. I topped it with a meringue made of the three leftover egg whites, 6 tablespoons of sugar and 1/2 tsp cream of tartar. I beat the egg whites until foamy, added the cream of tartar and continued beating until soft peaks formed and then added sugar one tablespoon at a time until stiff peaks formed. I topped it, browned it, let it cool and then sliced it. Wonderful!"
"Oh Peggy, thanks so much for posting this wonderfully easy recipe! Everything was perfect...texture, thickness, flavor (and I really like the added butter...wonderful extra richness!) I've never had pudding that wasn't made with regular milk and I must admit I was a little nervous but the sweetened condensed milk worked perfectly! (And is superb as just plain pudding as well as in pie.) I used a graham cracker crust instead of regular pie crust, topped it with cool-whip & a few chocolate shavings and everyone loved it! I will most definitely be adding this to our repertoire of goodies! "
"While this pie may taste great as other reviewers have said, the instructions are extremely lacking in detail. For someone who has never made a chocolate cream pie before, there's nothing that tells you what steps to take next or what something should look like. For example, when you say to cook until thick, what does thick look like? And maybe I'm just too much of a novice cook, but the recipe doesn't say to chill it first before putting the meringue on, so is that what I'm supposed to do? It's really too bad. I'm sorry to say I wouldn't try this recipe again as there's just not enough time for trial and error to figure out what to do."
"Perfect pie! Very smooth, creamy, flavorful! Will definitley make this again. I did not make merinque. After pouring in pie shell, I laid a piece of plastic wrap on top of the filling, this prevented a skin from forming. About 6 hrs later, took the wrap off and was tickled to see no filling stuck to it. Just added whipped cream as topping when served. Thanks for sharing this recipe!"
"We used this recipe, and I didn't have time to make it. My son-in-law made it and it is really yummy. I am just going to use the filling recipe for pudding. It was great!!!"
"Yum, yum. Peggy this pie was great! The filling was creamy and very fudgy. I served with whipped cream and it was a big hit. I'll make this again and again. "
"I have made this pie twice and the first time the pie filling was a little too runny even after all of the time spent cooking it on the stove and being refrigerated. So the second time around I used an extra teaspoon of cornstarch and it came out perfect. The filling was yummy and firm as it should be. When the pie was cut into the filling didn't run out like the first pie. Just a little hint from me to you."
"I just finished making this pie....haven't cut yet but the consistency seems very good and I added 4 T. of cornstarch & also 6 T. of dark cocoa. "licked" the bowl and very tasty. I also added cinnamon. Would recommend...
"I'll add my hoorahs for this wonderful, easy pie! I used an extra tablespoon of both cocoa and cornstarch, but otherwise followed the recipe to a tee, and using the microwave to cook it made it almost effortless. A perfect, delicious chocolate pie!!"
"Amazing! Great texture and consistency. I made it just as instructed - but would advise after cooking the pie filling, while it is cooling, to lay plastic wrap directly over top to keep that yucky film from developing - which will cause a lumpy texture. Made for a GREAT Thanksgiving pie :) Thank you Texas!"
"I made this pie filling earlier today and forgot to add the egg yolks but it was still really good. I ended up throwing that pie away because my crust was a little raw and it tasted horrible. So I made the pie filling again and this time I remembered the egg yolks. I also added a little cinnamon. It is 10 times better than the first batch, which I thought was great!
This is so easy and I can't wait to serve it at Thanksgiving tomorrow!"
"Amazing!!! Best chocolate pie ever! The only problem i had was there was some sort of liquid separated from the chocolate and meringue. I used a graham cracker crust. It was fabulous! only lasted 24 hours lol."
"I would give this more than 5 stars if possible. It is fast and easy, and not pudding out of a box. I opted to use the whipped cream for times sake, will try meringue next time. I also used a grahm cracker crust this time."
"I made this yesterday and followed the directions exactaly, and it tasted good.........but it tasted very much like chocolate pudding in a pie, i don't know i guess i was expecting something else. ok so the next day it tasted much better, in fact i've had 2 pieces today, however it was still not quite stiff enough to get a nice slice out of it."
"Unbelieveable! This pie is so good and so simple! I was nervous about knowing when it was thick enough on the stove but it thickened up nicely. The only problem is is that I have to share it with a lot of people! The only change I made was to add about 1 t Cinnamon - great trick to anything chocolatey to make it more so."