By StaceyB on October 03, 2002
Photo by MrsCarter1
Photo by MrsCarter1
"These are my favorite peanut butter cookies. They are so delicious. Be sure to use real butter, that is the key to the best tasting cookies. I found the recipe in the Pillsbury Complete Cook Book."
Serving Size: 1 (25 g)
Servings Per Recipe: 27
"Stacey, this is a great recipe and you are right, real butter makes them taste so rich and yummy! Thanks for sharing!"
"This recipe is delicious! Yes, I used real butter. I used creamy peanut butter and I added in 1 cup reeses peanut butter chips! I'm a batter girl, and this is great by the spoonful or the cookie! Thanks!"
"Excellent! Just the way I like them. Crispy yet soft inside. Thanks for sharing!"
"My mom gave me this recipe years ago and they are so delicious!! I bake mine for about 9 minutes and take them out when they look underdone, as they harden up a lot after you take them out. We love our cookies soft and chewie. Sometimes I add a heaping tablespoon cocoa powder for a slight chocolate flavor. Yum!!"
"Wouldn't you know the first recipe I tried was something sweet and was very good. I didn't have crunchy/instead used creamy. They came out creamy with the outer edges having a slight crunch. Just the way we like them. Thanks"
"I had such a craving for peanut butter cookies. I always try to find recipies from recipiezaar because you can read the reveiws. I looked over many recipies and picked this one, I followed recipie exactly but I used creamy peanut butter and when I was done mixing the dough I picked some up in my hands about and rolled it until it made about a 2 inch ball. Placed 6 on one big cookie sheet without using the fork to flatten the cookies just left them in a ball and wow gourmet cookies, taste like you bought them in a specialty shop. Nice large 4 inch cookies, crispy outside chewy inside. This recipie is great!!! Thanks for sharing...yummy!!!!!!!"
"These were very good. Fast and easy to prepare and they kept their shapes well while baking. I found them a litle too salty and would reduce the amount called for next time."
"Boyfriend, the peanut butter cookie fanatic, says these are the best I've ever made! Very nice texture, soft and a little crunchy. I think this is my permenant PB cookie recipe. Thanks!"
"I made them extra large and soft. They tasted better than the ones you get at the mall stands. These are a hit and now my favorite cookies."
"Crispy and crunchy, just the way we like our peanut butter cookies. I got a real bonus, the mixture made 35 cookies, yay! Thanks for posting."
"These were good and had great flavor. Thank you!"
"I loved these cookies, the only change I made was , at the request of my sister in law I substituted Splenda for the sugars and they were just as fabulous. And I agree with you on the real butter, cookies don't taste as good without real butter. They are a weekly addition in our house."
"These cookies are simply delicious, I am a Peanut butter lover and they came out just right. I didnt add the extra sugar . they were perfect the way they were, and my kids also loved them. in y oventhey too about 11min. But these are delicious!! Thank you Stacey B!!!"
"I don't typically like peanut butter cookies but these are awesome! They are soft and chewy. I've used both creamy and crunchy PB and it turns out great either way! I've made these several times and even got another friend addicted to them. Thanks for posting!"
"I made these for work, and everyone loved them. Thanks for a yummy recipe!"
"These are wonderful! I actually made these earlier today for the first time, and I'll definitely be making them again and again. I manhandled mine though lol so didn't look as nice as Tunasushi's photo, but looks don't matter when they're all gobbled up in under 20mins!!! lol. Fantastic. Thank you for the recipe :)."
"These cookies were wonderful. I added a package of semi-sweet chocolate chips to the dough and they were out of this world. Thank you so much for the recipe."
"5 Star ALL THE WAY.........Great Flavor.....Just plain GREAT Peanut Butter Cookies!!!!! Thanks"
"These cookies are simple and delicious. I used a potato masher to make a design on them when I smushed them down. Also, in the last batch I added some cocoa powder as another reviewer had done. It was a nice addition to these cookies."
"Cookies came out great!"