By Moonbugz_ on June 05, 2002
Photo by WokRokr
Photo by WokRokr
"You'll be sorry you didn't grow up in Chicago, and eat one of those wonderful beef sandwiches from Carm's. This tastes identical. This wonderful recipe came from my sister Linda knowing how homesick I am for Chicago food. Start cooking 18 hours before you want to eat."
Serving Size: 1 (4230 g)
Servings Per Recipe: 1
"This was our first recipe we tried and we are glad we picked this one. We absolutely loved this! We used Bell Peppers instead of the sweet peppers and didn't cook them. They still tasted great! We've been telling people about this recipe and now we have to give them a copy. We used about a pound more of rump roast because we couldn't find anything smaller. We bought a large loaf of bread and toasted it, then spooned on the Italian beef (with the juice) onto the bread and cut it from there. Also, we found that if you only cook it for 12 hours, it still comes out nice and tender. Again, we are very happy that you posted this recipe. Thanks so much!"
"FANTASTIC!!! I made this for my family and guests this last weekend and it was a hit. I loved the giardiniera and peppers. I also served with cheese for those that wanted it. Thank you so much for sharing this wonderful recipe."
"Great recipe! I did make a few modifications - I could only find .7oz packets of the italian seasoning mix so I used 1 of the regular and 1 zesty italian, and I added an extra 10oz of broth, as my family likes extra sauce for dipping :) I also added about 1/2 of a thinly sliced yellow onion in with the green peppers and used provalone cheese. With that being said - 18 hours seemed a little excessive to me, my meat was ready to be shredded after about 5 and it still tasted amazing :)"
"Ridiculous!!!! This is so awesome!!! Made adjustments according to how I like it..including double broth/seasoning for crockpot cooking, then even made side batch of broth/seasoning on stove top JUST for dipping my Italian Beef Sandwich in (Chicago style). Also, threw on a slice of provalone and some shredded mozza before dipping whole sandwich in!! Wowzie!!! Go for it! Peppers, everything else, perfect. Works especially well if you live in Chicago and can buy the ingrediants from the source. All the workers at the store figured out what I was making by my ingredients alone and I bet they headed to Portillos tonight for dinner! Thank you!"
"This is amazing! Just like the sandwiches I've had in Chicago. I served them at our super bowl party and everyone loved them. I can't wait to eat the leftovers for lunch. Thanks so much for posting this!"
"I would give this 10 stars if I could! We used a 2 lb rump roast, trimmed the fat as much as possible, Good Seasons Italian Salad Dressing Mix Recipe #34573, 3/4 of a jar of pepperoncini, and since I couldn't find the giardiniera in the store, I made my own after scouring the net for a recipe Hot Italian Giardiniera Recipe #409984. The roast was done in about 7 hours, and smelled fabulous. Since DH loves crusty bread, I toasted it in the oven first before we made sandwiches, and just used some of the peppers from the crock pot to top the sandwiches. HEAVEN! I was worried about the spiciness, and it had a lot of heat that day, but the next day the leftovers were much more mellow. If you can wait and let it sit overnight after cooking, the reheat, the flavor is phenomenal. I can't wait to have some for lunch, my mouth is watering just thinking about it! Thanks so much for posting!"
"Definitely a keeper! I used a different cut of beef (I think it was a chuck roast?) and halfway through I thought uh-oh, this isn't working. But by the end of cooking, it had fallen apart and was fabulous. I have kids and went light on the pepperocinis and giardiniera but should have dumped it all in because it sweetened as it cooked. I didn't have green peppers and it was great without, though next time I'll put them in if I have them. The kids all ate it first time and said it was good, which is high praise indeed. My husband said to move it right over to my recipe book - I'll be making this again! BTW I used Good Seasons Italian Salad Dressing Mix Recipe #34573 since I didn't have any of the packaged kind on hand and it was great."
"I have never had Chicago Beef, so I cannot vouch for it being identical. However, I can say it is very delicious and we really loved it. Perfect tangy flavor. I don't usually like giardiniera, but I trusted the recipe and added it, and it did add a very delicious flavor. I also liked that rump roast isn't that greasy, so the au just was really good without that slick of fat on the top. Will definitely make again and again."
"Moonbugz, this recipe is GOLDEN!!! I have tried about 5 different Italian Beef recipes from this site and AllRecipes trying desperately to make a beef like those I grew up on in Chicago. While many of them were decent, they weren't excellent and they certainly weren't authentic. I grew up near Carm's and while it wasn't my favorite place to get beef's, it was a definite contender. I followed your recipe pretty closely. I used two 2.5 pound roasts, used 2 packages of Italian Seasoning, used 1/2 of a large jar of spicy pepperoncini and used half of a large jar of HOT giardiniera. I omitted the green peppers because I didn't have them and also because my favorite beef's never included green peppers (unless you added them to the side) and HOLY COW were these off the charts EXCELLENT! My husband is from New York and doesn't know what an Italian Beef is and he's never thought much of all my previous attempts at making it. He couldn't stay out of my crockpot before dinner was even done! That is a HUGE compliment! Also, using two smaller cuts of beef caused the cooking time to decrease quite a bit. Mine was falling apart by the 13 hour mark. I'm salivating just thinking about the leftovers today and the gravy bread the day after that! TO DIE FOR! This is my official favorite Zaar recipe of all time - brings me home! Thank you Moonbugz! OUTSTANDING!"
"Having been a life long Chicagoan until moving down to Dallas a few years back, I definitely miss being able to get to a good Beef sandwich. This may not be the best beef you ever had, but it is definitely better than most of what you would get back in Chicago. I followed the recipe to the T except for using 2 2-1/2 lb. roasts as opposed to one 5 pounder. The difference is that it cooks faster and started falling apart by hour #14. The only problem is trying to find a good roll (french rolls do not stand up). Great for parties and the prep is rediculously easy. Highly recommended."
"Oh, yum! I cooked 2 roasts, which together weighed a little over 5 lbs. Since we like highly-seasoned food, I added the full jar of both the pepperoncinis and the giardiniera. (The recipe doesn't specify, but the ones I used were 16 oz. each.) I also took another reviewer's advice and used 2 packets of the seasoning mix. I went to turn them at the 6-hour mark and discovered I'd accidentally set the dial on 'high'. The meat was totally done and falling-apart tender. The au jus is fiery hot and wonderfully flavorful. Can't wait for supper!"
"Went through all the Italian Beef recipes and chose this one since I'm originally from south of Chicago and wanted the taste I had grown up with. I actually got an "I love you" from Dh (who's never had an Italian Beef) for this one. It's that good. I would go to the max w/ the 'heat' next time."
"We cook a batched for the Super Bowl and everyone thoroughly enjoyed it. The taste reminded us of a "Ropa Joe" from the restraunt, Bahama Breeze. We will definitely make this again."
"I loved this. I did double the amount of the Good Seasons packets however.That seemed to give the BOOT I was looking for.Thank You Moonbugz and Recipezaar."
"Ok, this has the Wow factor! So awesome. I didn't use the peppers at all, since I don't like them, but it was great without them."
"Made for a large crowd including kids several weeks ago - went over really well plus its a 'no fuss' recipe. Didn't cook for the full 18 hours, didn't have any complaints about tough meat and it really fell apart when shredding."
"Made this for a picky family and they all loved it. Because most of them don't like spicy, I used mild giardiniera and only a few pepperoncini. It's almost as good as the best I've had and only as expensive as 2 or 3 sandwiches purchased in the restaurant with plenty of leftovers. The green peppers are a necessity. Now my kids know what I mean when I say I want mine "wet and sweet". We had a blast eating messy and laughing at each others looks of bliss while biting in."
"Great sandwiches! I used sub rolls for mine and also had a rump roast about 2 1/2 lbs. so I used 1 can of consommé although I did use the entire pkg. of Italian dressing mix. I was nervous about the pepperoncini so I only used about a quarter of a jar but it was no problem at all, not too spicy. I subbed some jarred roasted red peppers for the giardianella. Thanks for posting. Made for Cooking Tag mania 2013."
"I've never been to Chicago. Not sure if I will ever be. Made this for the Superbowl. The game wasn't good but these sandwiches sure were. Followed the recipe to a "T" Nice blend of flavors. Made the whole house smell wonderful.....almost couldn't wait until halftime. Didn't have to slave over a stove or grill. Actually got to watch the game. I would highly recommend this recipe. I can't wait to try with a nice venison roast. Thanks for sharing!!"
"I don't own a crock pot (had one in the 70's and used it once). I couldn't find a rump roast ( tried four different stores). I was intrigued by this recipe and HAD to try it. I bought a four pound bottom round ( the largest I could find) and prepared it as written in my cast iron enameled dutch oven. I put it on the cooktop on high until it really got cooking, then turned it down to a nice simmer. Four and a half hours later, the meat shredded perfectly. I told my husband that if I had this out at a restaurant, I would return and order it again. He said that if he had it at a restaurant, he might never leave!! When this was cooking, the aroma was other wordly. The taste is even better. I've tried a lot of recipes from this site, and this one is the best."