By Paulcm on April 25, 2002
Photo by Botta-Bing!
Photo by Botta-Bing!
"I can't remember how I came across this BUT This is an WONDERFUL QUICK alternative to the traditional pumpkin pie. It has replaced all other pies at any gathering."
Serving Size: 1 (131 g)
Servings Per Recipe: 6
"This was so easy and so yummy. I brought it to a family function and everyone loved it. It is really creamy and I can't stress how easy is was to make. I think for thanksgiving I am going to make one traditional pumpkin pie and one of these."
"My husband says this is the best pie he's ever had! I was really surprised by his reaction considering how completely effortless this pie was to make AND I substituted light coolwhip, neufchatel cheese, used sugar free pudding mix and splenda instead of confectioner's sugar! It's practically guilt-free! A definite keeper and WAY EASY!"
"Excellent! I made my own crust from spice cookies where my husband accidentally used all blackstrap molasses. The cookies had been inedible on their own, but they made an unforgettable crust--so good. I used stevia and vanilla w/whipping cream, and it worked fine. I love pumpkin, and will make this again, next time doubling for a crowd!"
"I cannot believe how many compliments and recipe requests I got from making this recipe! It was delicious & so incredibly easy to make, I made it again just for kicks!
Note: I only used 1/4 Cup of Splenda (instead of sugar) and it was perfect!!"
"Overall this recipe is fantastic. Wish I could give it 4 1/2 stars! Two slight negatives: First, the cream cheese layer was very very sweet for our tastes. It almost tastes like more of a cream cheese icing to me. Next time I'll just cut the sugar in half. The pumkin layer is sweet enough to provide a nice contrast to a slightly less sweet cream cheese layer. Second, I know the recipe says to let the pie set for at least an hour. Ours took several hours. Next time I'll make it in the morning or night before to give it plenty of time to set. Having said all of that, this is such an easy recipe, we will definitely work on perfecting a version that works for us! Thanks!"
"Love this Pie! Learned to make it with my 2nd graders last year! It has become a hit with all the family!!!"
"We loved this pie! My son is allergic to eggs, so we are always looking for safe alternatives for traditional desserts. It is a "milder" version of pumpkin pie, but I noticed even kids and non-lovers of pumpkin pie devoured it! Definite keeper. Thanks!"
"I've been looking for this recipe online for literally 5 years! Someone use to make it for me and I thought I'd never have it again. When I saw this I thought this might really be it, although never having made it myself I couldn't know for sure until I made it. Well, Ta - Dah! I'm ecstatic to finally be reunited with this shamefully delicious, no-bake pie. Thank you so much!"
"Wonderful! I made it with a gluten free gingersnap cookie crumb crust. Thanks so much!"
"This is a wonderful pumpkin pie alternative. My husband, who is a sworn pumpkin hater, has even decided it is worthy of TWO slices after dinner. Thanks for Sharing Paulcm!!"
"I made this for a Keno night with a bunch of ladies I work with. It was a huge hit and they made me e-mail it to the entire school building the next morning. I used light cream cheese, 1/2 confectioners sugar and 1/2 Splenda and skim milk and it still turned out awesome."
"My husband made this pie for thanksgiving this year. We absolutely loved it. No changes were made."