By zoe,owen,andliams mommy on March 27, 2007
Photo by May I Have That Recipe
Photo by May I Have That Recipe
"This is another family favorite"
Serving Size: 1 (114 g)
Servings Per Recipe: 12
"No need for an extra pot! I have made this several time now, and every time I dump all ingredients (except pasta) into the crock pot and stir well. Then add the pasta a little at a time and mix well to coat. It comes out beautifully every time! I have also dressed it up a bit by adding chunks of cooked ham, fried onion bits, chopped mushrooms, and a few dashes of hot sauce. My husband loves it, and it was a hit at a office pot luck. thanks for posting!"
"Made the following changes: Melted some smoked gouda cheese with the sharp cheddar. Used cream instead of milk for added smoothness. Dropped in a bit of Dijon mustard instead of dried mustard and a bit of red hot for some zing. Heavily salted the water when boiling the elbow mac which helped to develop the flavor overall. I used a liberal amount of salt and pepper when mixing cheese sauce for flavor. When adding the warm cheese mixture to the eggs, I tempered them first so that I didn't end up with scrambled eggs in the mac and cheese. Not much flavor when I made this prior to making these changes."
"This is a great recipe for the crockpot! I made this recipe to take to a potluck. I par-cooked the noodles for 5 minutes, drained and cooled them, and then mixed all of the ingredients (minus eggs) in my cold crock and put it in the fridge overnight. Took it to work the next day and plugged it in-- 2/5 hours later, a party success! I decided to leave the eggs out because i was not cooking it right away. It was very creamy, and the noodles did not get mushy. I miss the crunchy topping that baked macs get, and I think the next time I'll add some paprika or extra pepper for a kick."
"I make this all the time! I omit the eggs also and I've also tried it with different grated cheeses such as Jack. When I use Jack cheese, I add some extra seasonings and once the macaroni is cooked, I mix in some crispy bacon, yum!"
"I couldn't find the recipe I previously used with great success for a company pot luck, so I tried this one. After draining the pasta, I immediately knew I was going to have to double the recipe and jimmy the recipe a bit, since I didn't have double of everything. So, I made another 2 cups pasta, for a total of 4.5 cups uncooked. I used 5 cups shredded sharp cheddar cheese, the same 1 can of soup, 1 stick of butter, 8 ounces sour cream, 2 eggs and double the seasoning. It came out so yummy and not grainy at all, but the pasta held their shape perfectly. I cooked the pasta for 6 minutes each time. I cooked on low for 2.5 hours as it wasn't quite hot enough for my taste at 2 hours. I won second place at the pot luck out of 20 dishes, and only lost to a yummy chocolate dessert. Will definitely make again!"
"I thought is was okay. Based on the reviews that I read, I left out the eggs. Aside from that, I followed the recipe. I thought the sour cream flavor was too strong, I may have liked it better without that. It was very creamy, but was kind of bland. Not worth the calories...I wouldn't make it again."
"This was not good. I made it exactly as the recipe said to do, including adding the eggs. It was awful. After about 2 hours in the crockpot it became apparent that the cheese was starting to curdle. And when we tasted it, the macaroni had the texture of mush and there was very little flavor. The whole batch went into the garbage and we opened a can of soup and had that for supper instead. Very disappointed."
"Best Mac & Cheese EVER!<br/><br/>With a few simple tweaks, this recipe is to-die for! Like other reviewers, I also omitted the eggs. For added flavor, I used a can of Fiesta Nacho Cheese Soup instead of regular cheese soup, a bit of Velveeta cheese and some Chipotle Cheddar Cheese, which adds a smoky creaminess with a bit of a kick. And just in case you are watching your waistline, I used light sour cream and light butter instead of the regular. This is a must-have dish!"
"AMAZING....BEST MAC & CHEESE EVER! Last night I made this recipe for the first time. I omitted the eggs and while cooking the noodles for the few minutes I just combined everything else in the crockpot. Once the noodles were drained I just added them to the crockpot and stirred real good, with the hot noodles coming into the crockpot it pretty much melted the butter and cheese. I did not have Sharp Cheddar Cheese so I had to use Colby Jack, but I think I like it better then if I had the Cheddar Cheese.<br/>This turned out so good that between three people there was no left over. So this evening I made this again, this time I doubled the ingredients (still omitted the eggs) and once again used the Colby Jack Cheese. Its so delicious! <br/>Its creamy and just overall awesome comfort food. This recipe will be at the top of my crockpot recipes!"
"Tasted good but the sauce curdled. I did temper the eggs. I considered not putting in eggs and I shouldn't have.Doubled the recipe, used 2 lbs sharp cheddar and 8 oz jalapeno cheddar."
"I am not going to rate this as maybe I didn't do something correctly. I made as directed but the texture was not good for us and everyone was unhappy,"
"Very good. very easy to make and doesn't require a lot of time in the crock pot, either.<br/>At first I didn't think the cheese was going to turn out right but it turned out just fine once the milk was added. Received a lot of compliments."
"Pretty dang good. I made the following changes: I used 3 cups of rotini, medium cheddar cheese, no eggs, light sour cream, 2% milk (about a cup and a half), no dry mustard, and seasoned pepper. I put everything in the crockpot on high while I cooked the rotini, then cooked another hour once I added the rotini ( I accidentally cooked the rotini for 8 min, so I didn't want to leave it in the crock pot too long). Turned out great. I used maybe a little more than a half tsp of salt, then thought it was too salty... So I added a little milk (hence the cup and a half instead of one cup). A little sauce-y, but still very good. Oh, and I only used 2 tbsp of butter."
"Made this for Easter dinner! Our family just loved! Will be making it again!"
"I did not like this mac n cheese (I would have given it 3 stars). I thought it needed something more. BUT I took this to a pot luck and people RAVED about it. Actually when I was taking my crock pot home, somebody stopped me and said..."that's the mac n cheese I heard about." (the 4 stars) I personally think it would have been better with a velveeta cheese instead of the sharp cheddar. Also, I didn't add the eggs but followed the rest to a T."
"This is good...not to die for. I had 2, 2 year olds that loved it but I wasn't over the moon. Made it as written but next time will leave out the eggs and see how that works...I wonder if they made it temperamental? Anyway, thanks for the recipe GiddyUpGo and Paula..."
"I hate eating healthy, though we have been trying to do so, per the doctor. (Just TRY to eat a little healthier!) This was a snow day treat....oh yeah!! I omitted the eggs and used 2% milk. I also had a 7-quart Crock pot, so I doubled the recipes and we have plenty of leftovers to snack on later. It was pretty awesome! Husband loved it. Still, as most things with PD, it was sooooo heavy that I know we can't have this very often. If more recipes could taste like this, without a Surgeon General warning (butter, cheese, Yum! Wait....Bad, Bad! No, good...it tastes so GOOD! ugh!) I would be a happy woman."
"I love this recipe.. I skip the eggs as well and sometimes it doesnt even make it in the slow cooker.. its sooo delish!"
"Making this for the 2nd time now. DH loves it (so do I). Definitely not for the calorie-conscious, but so good! I omit the eggs and use a good quality cheddar block, cut into pieces. Comes out so creamy and cheesy. Using a crockpot liner this time to cut down on post-meal scouring! :)"