By Mimi in Maine on February 16, 2007
Photo by michellet004
Photo by michellet004
"These are good. Filling is extra fluffy and delicious. It is not a sugary filling. The pies are extra chocolate-ty and soft. Wrap them individually in a baggie and freeze for later or eat all of them now."
Serving Size: 1 (1209 g)
Servings Per Recipe: 1
"These came out perfect! I even messed up a little. While making the filling I read the recipe wrong and accidentally mixed the sugar in with the milk and flour. I was short on sugar so I kept the mixture and boiled it with the sugar. It still came out great!"
"My mom used to make these for us when I was a child, and even thinking of them makes me smile. They brought back such memories for me while I was mixing them up. The filling came out perfect and with the chocolate of the whoopie pies and the filling it was a double taste sensation that I love love love!!! I made some big ones, so it only made 6. The bigger the better is my motto :)"
"Anyone that knows how to bake can make these taste like heaven just by following the recipe. I loved that they are not overly sweet. They are just like the whoopie pies my grandmother used to make for us and everyone wanted another that I offered them to!"
"They have been a family favorite for many years. I am so glad to have found this recipe!"
"The filling is not supposed to be overly sweet and these are exactly as they are supposed to taste. Anyone from New England knows that :) They are awesome!!!"
"I don't know why these got a low rating. They are GREAT! I made just as recipe directed. First of all the filling in Whoopie Pies isn't supposed to be real sweet like frosting. Secondly, if you mix everything in well and measure accurately with the flour (spoon the flour into the measuring cup and not scoop it into the measuring cup to let air in) they will come out wonderfully. Don't be put off by the bad reviews. Let's remember not everyone knows how to cook and bake using the same techniques, and if you measure correctly this recipe will come out for you and you will love them! Thanks Mimi"
"I have made these for years and have improved the filling. Mine is made of 1/2 cup marshmallow 1/2 cup of crisco 2 cups of conf. sugar.1 tbsp. of milk 1 tsp. of vanilla. Hope you enjoy"
"These were good but they need a little tweaking. The cookies were okay but the filling needed more flavor. Perhaps adding more sugar or using part butter instead of all shortening in the filling would help. Edited to add: These were much better the next day after being refrigerated. I still think the cream filling can be improved though. It's good but it doesn't quite make me say oh these are wonderful. I will definitely make these again though. Perhaps for variation I might add a drop or two of peppermint extract to some of the filling and maybe a dollop of peanut butter to some of the filling."