By chefnini on January 04, 2006
Photo by run for your life
Photo by run for your life
"A very good broccoli cheese soup. Served with crusty bread."
Serving Size: 1 (445 g)
Servings Per Recipe: 4
"I just read about a hundred of these reviews...I think its funny how people say "this doesn't taste at all like Panera" and then go on about how they changed this and that part of the recipe when they tried it:-) I have not yet made this, but when I do I'll be using vegetable broth (not sure if I should use that or chicken-style vegetarian broth). Even so, a suggestion that might be helpful. The people that say it was flavorless...my guess is if you use a high quality sharp cheddar like Cabot instead of Kraft it will make it much more flavorful. And then it seems like most of the people that really disliked this recipe said it was much too thick. The recipe didn't specify whether or not to cover while simmering, but that can impact how thick the soup is as can the size/shape of the pot and what your definition of a "simmer" and "low heat" are, among other things. Its easy enough to replace water that has evaporated or add more broth (depending on how the too thick soup tastes)...silly to grudgingly eat it or throw it out because its too thick!"
"This soup is delicious! I did add some garlic to the onions, and sauteed the carrots (which I grated) with the onions and garlic. Just a note about curdling....the lower the fat content in the milk product (half & half, milk, cream, etc) you use, the higher your risk of curdling. The higher fat content protects it from curdling as easily. That being said, you can still use low or no-fat products, but you have to take great care not to let them boil. My suggestion would be to make the soup all the way through, and add the milk products and cheese at the very end and heat gently, and slowly."
"This was an awesome soup. And whether this tastes exactly like Panera who cares, it is fantastic. I think you would have to have a side by side taste test to even compare, and lets face it , if you don't use the exact brand names of what Panera uses it won't taste the exact same anyways. Reading all the previous reviewers about the nutmeg was getting me nervous but I wanted to try the receipe as written and I did and I was worrying for nothing. The flavors were outstanding. The only thing I changed was I grated the carrot instead of julienned and I used my immersion blender in it for just a few seconds at the end. Everything turned out fantastic. I loved it and it is such a filling soup too. This is a soup I will be making again. Thanks so much for sharing chefnini."
"Wow! I am freaking out right now because I just made Panera's Broc/Cheddar soup in my own kitchen! It tastes exactly like their recipe. I just wish I had made bread bowls to go with it! I would give it 500 stars! It thickened up great and tasted amazing! This is a true 5 Star winner!"
"This recipe is ABSOLUTELY GREAT, DELICIOUS! I have made 2 or 3 times and the only thing I have changed is the fact that I use fresh brocoli that I prefer to steam and chop before using it in the recipe...the rest I do exactly as the recipe calls for...if not to follow the recipe why botter looking up for a specific recipe?
Congratulations to CHEFNINI."
"This is the best recipe for broccoli soup I have came across!! I do not understand why people search for recipes just to change everything about it and then complain and rate low because it wasn't as good as they had hoped. First off why not try the recipe first and then make changes the second time if any are needed. The flour in this recipe is very very important. The first time I made the soup it was so creamy and delicious, I raved about it and my boyfriend begged me to make it again a week later so I did but this time the creaminess was this weird texture and I thought I had everything in the pot so I though maybe the cheese was no good or something since it had completely separated from the soup base. I gave it another try last week and the same thing, the cheese separated from the soup base. Came back to this recipe sine it worked so well the first time and realized I forgot the flour. Please learn from my repeated mistake and don't forget the flour. I have tried the Cracker Barrel Extra Sharp Cheddar, the Tillamook Extra Sharp and the smoked sharped and liked the Tillamook extra sharp the best. :) Yummmmmmmy this soup is amazing!! Thank you for being so selfless and not keeping it to yourself."
"I get cravings for this soup and was so happy to try it out at home. I quadrupled the recipe so I could put some in the freezer and it turned out beautifully! I chopped the broccoli in the food processor, so no need to blend after cooking. Also used freshly ground nutmeg. Perfect!"
"Great recipe. Makes me want to round house kick someone through window. You don't have to blend it. Just mush up the broccoli with a spoon after its cooked and soft. Also add some more chicken stock if its too viscous or some flour if its too liquidy."
"Absolutely amazing. It's a huge pet peeve of mine when people rate and change the recipes, but I'm going to have to be an offender. I took the suggestion of other reviewers and used 2% milk rather than half and half and also subbed chicken stock with chicken broth (no big deal). I used Kraft sharp cheddar cheese, but it needed more flavor so I threw in a few slices of extra sharp cheddar. I shredded the carrots and added potatoes as well. The one suggestion I would make is to cook on light covered because my veggies were a lil crunchy. After stirring and covered for about an hour (paranoid about letting it burn), it reached the optimum consistency and taste! I would definitely recommend this recipe, boycotting Panera... chefnini you are my go to now!"
"I have to stress what other reviews say about the importance of your cheese choice. I used whatever was on sale at the grocery store...and it turned out that the soup was very, very bland. Next time I'll have to try something with much more flavor."
"I make this at least once a month. My family loves it. I also replace the broccoli with asparagus instead and it comes out awesome!"
"excellent! used 1 cup 1/2 and 1/2 and 1 cup 1% and it was a good consistency."
"I've made this recipe on several occasions, exactly as the recipe is written. It tastes exactly like Panera's Broccoli Cheddar Soup, every time. Don't rate a recipe if you chose not to follow the recipe exactly as written. Of course, add your modifications, but if it doesn't turn out like Panera's, don't blame the recipe, blame it on your changes of the basic recipe."
"Thumbs up for this soup at our house. 2% milk worked well and also thinned the soup a bit (personal preference). Used Cabot Vermont Cheddar for extra taste - and the nutmeg certainly made it special. Loved the addition of carrots too - anyway to get veggies into the family is greatly appreciated. Thanks for sharing chefnini!"
"I have made this soup numerous times. I usually make it when we have broccoli that is about to expire, which is at least once a month :).
I make it basically as stated, I don't think I add anything, maybe extra cheese or pepper. This is delicious and I will actually be making it for dinner tonight!"
"Oh so good! I'm 17 years old, if I can make it, so can you!"
"Haven't tried Panera's but this is hands down the best broccoli soup I've ever had.
I used whole wheat flour instead of regular as it gives a nuttier flavour to the roux, just personal preference. I grated the carrots and minced the broccoli florets very fine. Also added just a bit more stock to thin it out. I tasted it before adding the cheese and it was still fantastic. AMAZING soup."
"OMG! This is so good! Panera's soup is what got me started eating broccoli and this is almost identical except better texture. You know you are biting into something with this soup. Thanks so much! I will never go to Panera again!"
"This soup is so good ! I've made it twice now, once with frozen Broccoli and once with fresh, both worked equally well. Both times I used 2% Milk instead of Half and Half. Yummy ! Thanks for sharing your recipe"
"My boyfriend made this for dinner tonight. First time he has ever made soup from scratch. He added a bit of garlic powder, about 1/2 a tsp. It was delicious! He said he would be making this again. I did a ingredient correction re: the broccoli. It says 1/2 lb. broccoli but it doesn't say what to do with it. I added: chop into bite size pieces. A lot of novice cooks would not know this and I thought it would help."