By Delish on October 07, 2005
Photo by Redsie
Photo by Redsie
"This is simple to make and has basic ingredients that you keep on hand. The vanilla frosting tastes delicious spread on cakes or whatever suits your fancy."
Serving Size: 1 (300 g)
Servings Per Recipe: 1
"thank you so very much for this recipe. o.k., i just have one thing to say, this frosting was simply superb. very easy and quick to make. and tasty too. now why would some people say it was to sweet.not true at all. it was perfect for us. the second time i made it, i did add 1 more tbsp of milk to thin it out...made like a glaze. yum!"
"Thank you, thank you for keeping it so simple! A really tasty recipe that i improvised upon by adding a little cocoa powder to for a quick and easy chocolate frosting! Thanks again, we loved it!"
"TERRIBLE dosen't work or spread properly dont make it!"
"Yuck.. This frosting is too thick too sweet."
"simple easy recipe. Decent considering time spent and simple ingredients"
"wow great i goes great with lemon cupcakes and i would totally make it again simple and easy and donn't forget delicious!!!"
"Amazing!! I had all the ingredients here at home and it was quick and easy! To the people who didn't like it and said it was too thick, try adding a little more milk and mixing more!"
"This formula is perfectly fine. It you can write a review, then you're smart enough to know that you can heat a simple frosting -like this up- to thin it out. I did 4 increments of 6 seconds on the gas stove and it was the perfect consistency. Completely fine."
"This was an excellent frosting. I only used 1 1/2 cups of powdered sugar and added 1/2 cup of cream cheese and put in fridge to chill for 2 hours. It was delicious for my 24 chocolate cupcakes!"
"This frosting is super duper sweet so I recommend you add about three heaping dollops of sour cream. It is much nicer then. I like the simplicity of it though."
"For a powdered sugar recipe, I really wasn't expecting much. I couldn't drive to the store, so I figured it was worth a shot. I normally don't add the butter or margarine variation though, so this was a thrilling experiment. I was pleasantly surprised by the texture and flavor of this frosting. It had a nice medium-paint-thick consistency (definitely not in the glaze category as most powdered sugar icings are). It was smooth as ironed sheets and had a nice sugary-vanilla flavor. I refrigerated the leftover frosting, and I think I liked it better cold for breakfast this morning. The color was a little off due to the vanilla extract, but food coloring could fix that if you are all fancy and stuff. I paired this frosting with an easy cupcake recipe, found here: http://www.food.com/recipe/simple-white-cupcakes-172550"
"I tried this recipe he other day and right away I knew that there was WAY to much powdered sugar in it. So when I made this frosting, I cut the sugar in half and added a few drops of almond extract to give it a little flavor. Everyone loved it after I added the extract and I will probably use it again."
"Nice and simple. But also VERY powdered sugary-ie needed a little more butter. And Cream Cheese to make it perfect."
"This is a decent recipe for the time and ingredients required.
Those who are complaining about the thickness must not have used an electric mixer, which is a necessity for light and fluffy confections. It was still a bit thick and powdery, and did not yield enough for my 2-layer cake, so I quadrupled the recipe, and then added a splash more of milk (about 1-2 tbs more) to the mix. It was still a bit powdery, but it worked well with my strawberry cake. For those of you using this on drier cakes, try adding even more milk to the mix."
"This recipe is perfect for an 8x8 pan of brownies. I added some melted chocolate chips and a teaspoon of peppermint extract and it is so good. My sister thought it was a new store bought frosting. It's really smooth and creamy."
"Kid approved! Easy recipe, and my kids loved it. I used whipping cream instead of milk and that seemed to make all the difference. Added a little more cream then called for to make a thinner consistency. Overall great recipe!!"
"I made this within 2 minutes!!! It was a lifesaver as I did not have any icings in the house. I just added 1 extra tablespoon of milk and it iced a 2 layer cake. Next time I will add root beer flavoring to make a vanilla root beer cake.You can use any flavoring you like."
"Good foundation. Basic and useful BUT I changed/added a lot to this: 2 tablespoons of butter for each cup of powdered sugar. I made a lot of icing today, probably used 10 cups of powdered sugar, 2 and 1/2 sticks of butter, 6 dollops of sour cream and 8 oz of cream cheese. It is DELICIOUS. added vanilla to my liking."
"Very easy, lovely texture. Little sugar headache just from licking the beaters though! I'm a fan of a cream cheese frosting, but will come back to this in a pinch when the stores are closed for an ice storm- like today!"