These taste like a peppermint shortbread cookie. I am not that fond of shortbread and would have given them 3 stars, but people at work said they were amazing, so i'm averaging it out to four stars. I cooked them for 13 minutes a batch and got 40 cookies out of it. I used 12 peppermint starlight mints and they came out to 3 PP per cookie. I made these for PAC Spring 2013.