184 Reviews

This cake is a time consuming recipe. I've made it dozens of times from a recipe (exact) that didn't give the Waldorf credit. It is delicious. The icing has a wonderful flavor that does not compete with the rich, but delicate chocolate cake. If you are a red velvet fan-This is the Gold Medal of all Red Velvets.

61 people found this helpful. Was it helpful to you? [Yes] [No]
Childrens Minister March 26, 2002

This is a wonderful cake that we use for only real special occassions. I would llike to make one ammendment. The cake is much better when you use 1/2 vup of real butter instead of shortning.

55 people found this helpful. Was it helpful to you? [Yes] [No]
Eddy May 28, 2002

this is a wonderful recipe..i found this same recipe in an old shed on my property with a note attached dated aug 1959 ,It stated the person received this recipe by paying the hotel 250.00 for it..it is a wonderful cake ..has great flavor I highly recommend it!!!

30 people found this helpful. Was it helpful to you? [Yes] [No]
katiekre July 11, 2002

1st of all - thank you troyh for posting this recipe. It was published in our local newspaper back in the 70's when I was 7. We tried it; loved it; lost the recipe. It has always been my most favorite cake ever! Okay, now on to some other things about what previous people said. A) It really is granulated sugar, not confectioners. It will dissolve if you whip it properly. It will be grainy until after you add the flour/milk paste - that it when it really smooths out. B) Definately use fresh cake flour. If it's been in the cabinet for 6 months, go buy some new. C) This is not a chocolate cake - it is red velvet cake, named not only for the color, but the unique taste. Don't expect a chocolate cake just because their is cocoa in the recipe. D) Make sure your flour/milk paste is smooth - lumps will kill your frosting. Trying sifting the flour as you stir it in to the milk. I found that to help. E) If you found the cake to be dry, it was overcooked. This cake recipe is tried and true but very sensitive. F) Serve this cake slightly cooler than room temperature - it really brings out the flavor of both the cake and the frosting. G) The amount of frosting is usually sufficient for most. It makes enough to fully frost and fill an 8 inch round moderately. If you like a really thick layer, double the recipe. Made properly, this cake is AMAZING! NOTE: If you really want to replicate what the Waldorf does, find some edible gold leaf and top off your cake with a bit of sparkle!

17 people found this helpful. Was it helpful to you? [Yes] [No]
mlmphantom November 15, 2008

This cake is to die for! I made this cake and also made mini red velvet cupcakes for my Birthday and my family and friends loved them. The cake is so moist, with a wonderfully delicate chocolate flavor, and not too sweet. I did change the recipe a little, for any Aussies out there instead of shortening, I used full cream Tasmanian butter, and for the colouring, I used Queens Pillar Box Red, 25mls (1/2 bottle) which I added to the milk. I also sifted the cocoa in with the flour and salt, it makes for a much lighter batter and fluffier cake. An excellent recipe, definitely one to keep.

12 people found this helpful. Was it helpful to you? [Yes] [No]
mamaJing November 19, 2010

Five Stars! After reading the mixed reviews I was hesitant about blindly relying on this cake for Thanksgiving dinner so decided to take a test run by halving the recipe and making cupcakes. OMG! Where to begin. I was blown away by the melt in your mouth moist, tender texture of this cake. In fact, the cupcakes were so moist and delicate that they literally fell apart when touched. When eating them I had two choices: eat them directly from the wrapper or eat them from cake smudged fingers. I made only one adjustment to the recipe, butter instead of shortening. I also kept a careful eye on them past the 15 min mark, checking every 5 mins. thereafter. They were done at the 25 min mark. For those having problems with this recipe three things come to mind: freshness of the ingredients, adequate creaming of the butter and sugar, and baking time. Use only recently purchased ingredients and cream the butter. And sugar until light and fluffy prior to adding the eggs and vanilla. A note on the butter: It should bend without breaking. If it breaks it' s too cold. If it's a globby mess it's too warm.) And finally I used a shifter to add the flour to butter mixture. I went with the frosting recipe given with a slight variation. I substituted two tablespoons of cream cheese for two tablespoons of the butter. The result was a creamy not too sweet frosting with a barely discernable twang. Today I am baking up a batch for my helpful friends down at the hardware store and can't wait to see their expressions of bliss when thy bite into sweet perfection. Thanks so much for this recipe!

8 people found this helpful. Was it helpful to you? [Yes] [No]
sweettooth12 November 22, 2011

Never cared for or understood Red Velvet Cake before, but it's a friend's favorite and I wanted to make her something special. Obviously I never tried this one before. WOW! This was light, moist, not overly sweet, fantastic! Thanks to all the reviews (I always read them before actually trying a recipe) I too cut back to 2oz of food color. Coloring was beautiful. Batter thin but rose perfectly level and high! I really don't find scratch cakes that much more difficult than box especially when the taste is so much better. Thanks for sharing - one I'll make over and over,

7 people found this helpful. Was it helpful to you? [Yes] [No]
Acceptance August 29, 2010

This cake was delicious and offered a dramatic presentation, with the dark red cake and the white frosting. Being the first time out with this recipe, I followed the instructions to the letter. A few call outs:

1. The cake came out perfectly moist and dense. For reviewers saying that it was too dry, try adjusting the temperature of your oven and/or cook time. Different ovens cook at different temperatures, and I've burnt a cake more than once by being too literal with the instructions.

2. The flour frosting was amazing - liked whipped cream, but doesn't melt. Next time, I plan to increase the amounts called for in the recipe. I used two 8-inch diameter layers for the cake, and didn't have enough frosting. I had to make a second batch.

3. I would definitely recommend using 2 oz. of red dye. It yields a rich, dark red color for the cake. One ounce of dye made the cake look bright red - sort of like a clown nose or a fire truck. Some of the charm and sophistication that should come with this cake was lost.

6 people found this helpful. Was it helpful to you? [Yes] [No]
mesavery December 26, 2011

Awesome!!! I tried other recipes but this came out perfect. I don't have cake flour so I use AP flour (I took out four tablespoon and a teaspoon)

6 people found this helpful. Was it helpful to you? [Yes] [No]
tee_osunjaye May 16, 2011

UPDATE: I found an easier to foolproof the frosting! Start with the milk first, then sprinkle the flour on top. Whisk continuously! Seriously, don't walk away from it! Just stand and whisk for a few minutes. Another tip, if you have a small food chopper or Magic Bullet, give your granulated sugar some quick pulses, and voila! Superfine sugar. If only I could give this 10 stars! I have already made this twice in less than 2 weeks! It's not as hard as it looks, it's just a lot of little steps. I know that this roux frosting is the real traditional frosting for red velvet, not cream cheese icing (although I do love that). I used butter, Hershey's Dark cocoa, and only 1 ounce of red food coloring (I really don't like to use dyes). I wasn't worried about it being dry because I've never really had a problem with dry cakes that used butter. The cake was moist, not too light, not too dense, and very tasty with that hint of chocolate (red velvet is NOT a chocolate cake, it's a buttermilk cake with a HINT of cocoa). However, I did have a little trouble with the frosting. So like another reviewer who also had lumps, I strained it. But I guess it wasn't enough because the frosting was still a little grainy (and like another user, I used granulated sugar since it was 'traditional'). So I made half of the roux mixture again, and put some of it in while it was still hot. This melted the sugar and produced a very smooth, silky, airy frosting that is absolutely amazing! My sister gave some to a friend (who loved the frosting because it wasn't too sweet and paid me to bake one for her!) and brought some to work. A coworker said it was perfect, and the frosting was light, so it makes you feel like you can eat a few more slices without feeling too heavy and rich! This is now a staple in my collection. Thank you soooo much for sharing!

6 people found this helpful. Was it helpful to you? [Yes] [No]
caffeine junkie April 06, 2009
Waldorf-Astoria Red Velvet Cake