- Most Helpful
- Highest Rating
This recipe is wonderful! My husband and I love it-which is good since there are only two of us, and it's alot of food. I made the potatoes with fat-free cream, and used a pound of meat instead of 1 1/2. Very good, and since it's already 22 degrees outside, this is a nice warm meal on a cold, cold night. I'll make it again!
I really didn't care for this recipe at all. Normally, I LOVE shepherd's pie. VERY disappointed. Here's what I think went wrong. The recipe calls for one 2oz pkg of onion soup mix. Onion soup mix comes two 1oz pkg's to a box. I think it should have been only one 1oz pkg. It tasted like PURE onion soup mix. It also did not hold up when I cut into it. It ran everywhere. It was also VERY salty, which may also be due to the extra onion soup mix. Won't be making this one again. sorry
This was really good. I didn't change anything. My husband and 3 kids all enjoyed it. I have never had Shepherds pie before tonight. I'm glad I went with your recipe. I will make it again for sure!