- Most Helpful
- Highest Rating
Like others I reduced the celery salt as we are very salt conscious--- used 1/8 teaspoon celery salt. Very nice tasting recipe. Thank you Sharon for sharing.
This was perfect for lunch! I made one change. Instead of using onion salt, I used onion powder and less of it. I really liked the addition on the celery seeds. It was served with vine ripened tomato slices, pickle spears and crackers. This will be made again! Thanks so much for posting, Sharon!!
Great tasting salad, I followed this exactly, and served it perched atop a lettuce leaf as the previous reviews suggests. Following the recipe, the onion salt is a bit high, so I am thinking the recipe author might mean 1/4 tsp. of onion salt. The celery seed and relish just tasted great, mellowed with the yellow mustard and mayonnaise a perfect combination. Thank you for a wonderful salad, (I threw some chopped green onions on top) and can hardly wait to make again. Made for *I Recommend* February 2009.
I'm giving this a 5 star rating based on ease of preparation, unique and satisfying flavor. I did read about the potential saltiness, so I opted for using onion powder versus onion salt. It tasted great. I always use either celery salt or celery seed and relish in my egg salad sandwiches, so I had a good hunch I'd like this. The onion powder, yellow mustard really made the flavor special. I ate this as is, no bread, and it made for a perfect no-carb lunch! Thank you.
This was so salty that I had to throw the sandwich out. I'm giving it 2 stars b/c I could kind of tell that without all the salt it would have tasted good. I will try it again with onion powder and a dash of salt and review again...
I made this for myself but halved it to use one egg. I used 1/4 tsp of the onion salt & next time will use 1/8 bc it was a teensy bit too salty but that was my fault. I absolutely loved the seasonings in this recipe!! Thx for posting!!
Loved this recipe. I used onion powder and celery salt, and only 1 T mayo, I also used fat free mayo but that is all I use. This was very good, made too much for one meal for me, so I will have rest of it as a snack later in the day. Totaled about 6 oz. and with the crackers that is just too much food, again for me. Made for Pac Fall '11
Yummy! Simple and good. Thanks for sharing Sharon. Made for Cookbook Tag.
This made a quick small lunch for me, DH and my son. It's so yummy and so simple. Thanks Sharon :) Made for Cookbook tag game
I have to give this 5 stars, because this is the way I always fixed egg salad! It's nice to get back to basics every once and a while. Enjoyed, very much. Thnx for sharing this much liked recipe, again, Sharon. Made for PAC Fall 2009.