- Most Helpful
- Highest Rating
Made this with coconut pudding. My DH loved it. I gave it 4 stars because I really prefer a traditionally made apple pie (filling thickened with a bit of flour or tapioca). Making another today using instant vanilla pudding. Maybe I'll like a bit more neutral flavor. But this is easy and quick to make with ingredients I always have on hand (I keep a pkg of Marie Callender's frozen pie crusts at all times). don't always have time to make scratch crust. I really like this crunchy topping!
I am only giving it 4 stars because for some reason I cannot get this pie to hold together. Every time I make it, it has more of an Apple cobbler texture. It completely falls apart. The taste is amazing though, and the pie was gone in no time, I added some cinnamon and some nutmeg, and it helped with color and flavor. If someone could please tell me how to keep my pie from falling apart that would be great. . . this is an awesome pie and I will continue to make it despite the falling apart aspect.
This is not a pie for apple lovers. I made the pie with instant french vanilla pudding, the texture was good and creamy but the color was bright yellow. There was a artificial after-taste, which may not be there with a cook and serve? My husband loves pudding but he didn't like the pie. I won't make this again, this is not an apple pie recipe.
Absolutely delicious! I made it for work and everyone loved it. I used the french vanilla but next time I am going to try the butterscotch. I'm hoping it will taste like a caramel apple. I have a large pyrex pie plate so I needed to use about 6 cups of apples but the one package of pudding mix was still enough to set the contents of the pie. Highly recommend this recipe.
I used only the topping for my own apple pie recipe, but I must say, the topping really made the pie. The topping would even be delicious if you rolled caramel apples in it. Thanks for the recipe!
think this recipe a little incipid and bland would not waste ingredients on it!
made it yesterday and it was "unbelievable" good.Gonna make it next time with pears.Think it would be very good with any kind of fruit.
I was surprised at how good this pie came out with how easy it is to make. I only had butterscotch pudding on hand and while my son commented on the color (he thought I added pumpkin) he and everyone else agreed it is a make it again pie.
The only change I made was to use butterscotch pudding and ambrosia apples
I made this tonight and it was Fantastic!! So easy and so good. Thank You for posting