169 Reviews

I must say...this recipe is HIGHLY recommended to all. I am a very particular about recipes; but THIS ONE IS A KEEPER. I used all the ingredients mentioned in the recipe as well as followed all of the instructions. The only thing that I did different, not on purpose, was use White Zinfandel wine, instead of red wine (I didn't have any red wine and didn't feel like driving down the mountain to get it when I had everything else cooking--lol). Unless you like that kind of wine, don't use it. When I buy more red wine, I will try it--so I could decided which one is best. Also, it really makes a difference when you season your potatoes and get them into a semi-creamy texture with butter and canned milk. Whip on HIGH with hand mixer. Just a thought, if you haven't tried it that way. : )

16 people found this helpful. Was it helpful to you? [Yes] [No]
msbabette March 19, 2011

Hubby has been asking for Shepherd's Pie for a couple weeks. Rather than my usual throw together, I decided to consult my Food.com peeps. Am I ever glad I did. This was amazing!!! Followed the recipe almost exactly, with the exception of using dried thyme and Sherry. For those concerned about not having red or white on hand, I have found that using Sherry for either is a great alternative. You can pick up a big bottle in any liquor store for about $6. For those concerned about the prep time, try using instant potatoes. They have changed so much over the last few years and honestly you cannot tell the difference. Our favorite is Idahoan Four Cheese. Remember too that Shepherd's Pie is one of those dishes that can be made earlier in the day and just tossed in the oven when you are ready. A chilled dish just takes a bit longer to heat.

12 people found this helpful. Was it helpful to you? [Yes] [No]
CowboysChick March 23, 2012

Excellent comfort food for a cool fall evening! I substituted a can of french cut green beans for the peas, used dried thyme and put some shredded cheese on top of the potatoes. It turned out delicious!

11 people found this helpful. Was it helpful to you? [Yes] [No]
AngelaKL77 October 23, 2009

Fantastic flavor! Excellent re-heated for lunch the next day. Like so many here, I am VERY particular about recipes. Made it exactly as the recipe states. LOVED it! Will make it again over and over. Highly Recommend!

5 people found this helpful. Was it helpful to you? [Yes] [No]
broby7777 July 22, 2013

? I just wanted to thank you for this marvelous recipe. I?ve had a taste for shepherd pie for weeks now and Google guided me to this one. My husband is a picky eater and wanted to know why I was going though all the fuss on a week night. Guess what, he loved it and didn?t leave a crumb.<br/>? Thanks again

5 people found this helpful. Was it helpful to you? [Yes] [No]
drmoore April 11, 2013

I used this recipe as a guide adding 1/4 cup sour cream, 1/4 cup softened cream cheese, one beaten egg and 1/2 cup Irish white cheddar to the potatoes and 1 1/2 cups Chianti Ruffino, 1 cup low- sodium beef broth with 3 Tbs Masa flour to 2lbs of ground lamb- my wife tasted it and said it needed 1/2 cup beef broth and 1 cup additional frozen peas and she was right, of course. Freshly grated quality Parmesan chesse sprinkled on top was a nice touch. I was hoping to bring in some to work tomorrow but my family devoured it.

5 people found this helpful. Was it helpful to you? [Yes] [No]
ronstaiger March 04, 2013

Wow! This was great. I fell in love with Shepherd's Pie while living in Rhode Island for about 6 months. Between Providence and Boston I got to sample different varieties of this hearty and comforting food. This recipe is a keeper. Although I wouldn't exactly classify this as a quick, after-work meal prep (unless you happen to have leftover mashed potatoes), it is easy to prepare. You could probably take some shortcuts with instant potatoes (yuck), but the recipe as written is just too good to pass up! Absolutely perfect for a winter-time dinner! Thank you for sharing...

5 people found this helpful. Was it helpful to you? [Yes] [No]
bobbyfrass January 19, 2012

Made this for an Irish party and it went over very well. People that had had Shepherd's Pie before thought this was the best ever!<br/>I doubled it and next time will do the same but use a smidge less Worcestershire sauce. I did use ketchup instead of paste and I think it gave it a little sweetness that was nice.

4 people found this helpful. Was it helpful to you? [Yes] [No]
Mosskoet March 18, 2013

This recipe is great. It is a great starting point to a refrigerator cleaner. I used a parsnip I had in the fridge, some frozen green beans instead of peas and left over corn from a take out dinner. I used some veal stock I had in the freezer instead of chicken stock and used a wheat beer I made since I didn't have wine. I also had a piece of cheddar that was coming to expiration so I chopped it up and added it to the mashed potato. I used ground veal which was on managers special for $1.99 lb so I added some duck fat that was in the fridge to bring up the fat content. I used a trick from another recipe and used a fork to score the surface of the potato to encourage browning. Bottom line... use what you have and make a special meal from what is in the fridge and freezer and it will turn out great.

3 people found this helpful. Was it helpful to you? [Yes] [No]
Nancy K. July 23, 2014

Made recipe as stated. This will become a regular dish in our home! I will preassemble the on the weekend and pop in the oven on a busy week night. Very satisfying and nutritious comfort food that stretches a pound of ground meat into several satisfying meals. My husband is delighted and so am I.

3 people found this helpful. Was it helpful to you? [Yes] [No]
mizzbrooks April 09, 2013
Traditional Irish Shepherd's Pie