Sorry, but this did not turn out like I thought it should. The dough was so thick that I had to spread it using greased hands. There is only 3 eggs and 3 Tsp of OJ for moisture in the batter. The dough under the apples tasted ok, as it got a little sweetness from the apples. Some vanilla ice cream also helped. 9 apples came out to 10 cups of sliced apples just in case someone wonders. You might want to ask your aunt if there is suppose to be more liquid in this recipe. This is one of the recipes from Pick A Chef Orphanage 2006. I picked two of Eva99's recipes to make.