The Realtor's Blue Moon Ice Cream

READY IN: 3mins
Recipe by Realtor by day

There are many different theories about how this famous ice cream should be made. Nobody knows for sure because the recipe has always been secret. This is my version. I don't know if it's an exact duplicate but we love it this way. When you're finished, it should be sort of the color of smurfs so add food coloring until you acheive smurf blue. I use 40 drops. Splenda lovers- this will not turn out the same with splenda. I love it and sometimes I use it anyway but it does NOT give the same creamy consistency as regular sugar does. I don't know why but it just doesn't.

Top Review by AZPARZYCH

I am not a big fan of blue moon ice cream, but 4 yr old DS loves it so I gave this a try. It tastes just like the store bought version, but I like that it does not make a ton! Was very creamy and had a light flavor to it. The blue food coloring that I bought didn't have a dropper top (had a pour top) so I just poured in a splash or two...should have stopped at one, it was too much. No biggie though, just turned our mouths a little more blue than it was supposed to. Will be making this often in the summer and for family get togethers since there are five boys in the family that all love this!! Made for PAC Spring 2010.

Ingredients Nutrition


  1. Stir all of the ingredients together. Stir until sugar disolves. Pour into your ice cream freezer and proceed according to the directions for your ice cream maker. Don't tell anyone you're making it. They'll totally inhale this and you won't get any. Hide it!

Join the Conversation

  • all
  • reviews
  • tweaks
  • q & a