Super Deluxe Peanut Butter Sandwich

Total Time
Prep 15 mins
Cook 5 mins

This is to a peanut butter sandwich what a supreme sundae is to an ice cream cone. Healthier than either, but wow. My favorite reward lunch. Melty, sweet, savory,

Ingredients Nutrition

  • 2 slices 100% whole wheat bread (thick slices)
  • 2 tablespoons natural-style peanut butter
  • 1 tablespoon creamed honey
  • 1 small banana, sliced


  1. Place bread under broiler to that one side toasts.
  2. Spread peanut butter on the toasted side of one slice, and spread creamed honey on the toasted side of the other slice.
  3. Place banana slices on the peanut butter slice.
  4. Press together to make a sandwich (the untoasted sides should be out).
  5. Toast in a toaster oven or on a hot skillet until the out-facing sides are nice and crispy.
  6. Dig in!
Most Helpful

I had this for breakfast today. It was my first ever Elvis-style sandwich. I was impressed that it wasn't as full of fat and cholestrol as some of the similar recipes listed here - but from eating it, I couldn't tell! Since I don't have a toaster oven and didn't want to make the sandwich any more unhealthy than it has to be, I broiled the insides of the bread and assembled the sandwich as directed and broiled the outsides without adding any margarine or butter to them. My advice to anyone considering making this sandwich? If you don't have milk in the house, don't even bother! You're going to need it!

Ransomed by Fire April 14, 2010

This is real comfort food to me. I've eaten it for years. The only difference is that I just drizzle the honey on top of peanut butter. I think the toasting of the bread (wheat, 9-grain) really crispy is key for me. Roxygirl

Roxygirl in Colorado July 02, 2006

This seemed to take too long for a peanut butter & banana sandwich. I thought the honey made it too sweet, and I think I prefer mine on untoasted bread. I did mine in the toaster oven for step 5, and I think a skillet would give better results. It just wasn't what I had hoped. Sorry!

AWinPA June 25, 2006