Sunday Supper Gramma Richter's Potato Salad

READY IN: 55mins
Recipe by MadCity Dale

UPDATED: Serving again at August 2015 Sunday Supper in the outdoor "Can Shelter" at Warner Park, Madison, Wi. Serving at May 2015 Sunday Supper @ WPCRC, Madison, Wi. Grandmother Richter's potato salad that always had a stronger mustard taste than the Matthews family. She says boil potato first then peel. If not done this way NO GOOD, Enjoyed at many Richter clan get togethers when I was not working in the retail business during the get togethers. Grandmother Mike often referred to me as "What's his name?" Her humor was very bold and to the point. Always remember the morning after New Years when "what's his name" was feeling very lousy. That little tiny woman looked at me and says, " do you know the best cure for a hangover?" Nooppee! Mike looked at me and very lovingly, motherly, and sympathetic, says 24 HOURS,

Top Review by The Spice Guru

I loved this potato salad! I've been an underdog for Miracle Whip ever since I heard my own mother spew, "When I think of Miracle Whip, I think of trailer trash". This is an excellent recipe!

Ingredients Nutrition


  1. Cook red potatoes, peel when warm.
  2. Put eggs in pot, cover with water bring to a full rolling boil. Turn off heat and let sit 25-30 minutes, peel and slice.
  3. Mix all other items for dressing.
  4. Alternate layers of warm potatoes, chopped onion, and dressing.
  5. Then mix together and cool in refrigerator.
  6. Serve with sliced eggs and paprika on top.

Join the Conversation

  • all
  • reviews
  • tweaks
  • q & a