Stef's Best Chocolate Chip Cookies

Total Time
32mins
Prep 20 mins
Cook 12 mins

I love chocolate chip cookies, and have been playing around for years to find what I consider to be the 'perfect recipe.' This is a combination of recipes from a few different sources, I don't consider it original, more stealing the tips I like from different places (alton brown, the ny times, and paula deen, among others). I particularly like it because the butter is melted - it saves your arm the usual pain of mixing softened butter. These make cookies I like - slightly salty, think, chewy, and butterscotch-y. If anyone finds changes that work well, please let me know, this recipe is always a work in progress to me. Enjoy!!

Ingredients Nutrition

Directions

  1. Sift flour, salt and baking soda. Set aside.
  2. Melt the butter.
  3. Add white sugar, brown sugar to the butter, cream until bubbly.
  4. Add egg, yolk, milk and vanilla. Be very not to scramble the egg, you may want to let the butter mixture cool off.
  5. Add slowly flour mixture. Do not overmix, stop as soon as it is well combined.
  6. Add the chocolate chips, mix. The dough will not be mixable once chilled, so the chips must be fully incorporated.
  7. Chill the dough in the fridge overnight. 24 hours is always recommended, especially if grocery store vanilla is used. If you’ve never done this before, split a batch. Make half after an hour, save the other half until the next day. The difference is obvious in the way the cookie looks and the flavor, there’s an almost chemical tartness that the cookies lose after the 24 hours. I never noticed the tartness until I tried this, now I can’t ignore it.
  8. When ready to bake, scoop the cookies onto a parchment paper or silpat lined baking sheet in large round balls at least an inch apart. I use a non-stick ice scream scooper. Do not forget to line the sheet, these cookies will stick to a non-stick pan, even if greased. Sprinkle salt over the top of the cookies before placing in the oven.
  9. Bake the cookies in a well pre-heated (pre-heat for at least an hour) 375 degree oven for 9-13 minutes. Baking time will depend on how long the dough chilled, the cookies will brown better (and faster) if the dough sat for at least 24 hours. Rotate the baking sheet once.
  10. Do not overbake the cookies, they need to be watched carefully to make sure they don’t get too brown. The taste changes significantly (as with most brown sugar things) if they’re baked too long. I’ve had them take as few as 8 to as many as 14 minutes.
  11. Remove from oven, let cool for 5 minutes. Gently separate any cookies stuck together with a knife or spatula, then move to a cooling rack with the spatula. They should cool for at least 10 more minutes. The cookies will break if not properly cooled.
  12. Yield is 20-ish, it’s always different for me, since I make the cookies as big as feasible, the bigger the cookie, the better the contrast between crust & crumb.
Most Helpful

5 5

YIPPEE! A chocolate chip cookie that my husband LOVES and that I can make without messing up! Followed recipe exactly. It is exactly as Stephanie described - a little salty and chewy but perfect. Will keep it and make often! Made for PAC '10.