- Most Helpful
- Highest Rating
This was a great recipe. The only problem I came accross, is that it needs to be made at least a day in advanced for all the seasons to combine. After 1 day it was GREAT!! This is just like Corky's BBQ in Lexington KY.... Its one of the best you will every find.
This was very tasty and the dressing is super creamy! The reason I took off one star is because it didn't really blow me away, but it was really good. I may adjust the seasonings next time to reach the "wow" point. Goes great with BBQ brats & burgers.
This recipe rocks! The only reason I gave it 4 stars is because it could stand to have more chives. Also I used celery salt and I think a bit of season salt would give it more flavor. We had a barbecue last night and this was everyone's FAVORITE dish!
This is the most fabulous recipe! Every time I make it we get rave reviews! fantastic! don't change a thing!!
this was good...potatoes stayed well formed and everything...first time that ever happened for me. thanks for posting
I've never made potato salad w/out mustard, and I absolutely love it! I also added a bit of ranch dressing, boiled eggs, and olives...so good!! Thanks!
What a delightful recipe. I made it for a BBQ and everyone commented how lovely it was. I cubed my potatoes then boiled them. Lovely creamy dressing that coats potatoes well. Thank you for a perfect potatoe salad recipe! No need to look any further.
It's not like this recipe needs ONE more raving review :D but I'm going to anway! Made this today, after finally discovering there IS a recipe just like the deli at the store!! At first I wasn't going to make it, because I didn't have everything on hand, but after reading the reviews and saw some of the things subbed or ommitted, I decided it was it. I will say that the spices, really should be to taste. For myself and my DH, we prefer a bolder flavor with spices, so I just added a lil extra till it was the way I knew we'd both like it. Also, I had no bacon, so did as another reviewer did and add the last of some cooked ham I had from earlier this week. I boiled the taters instead of baking them, and honestly..I can't tell the difference. I honestly believe it's the taste of the dressing!! Definitely going into my "Do-Again" book. Thanks for sharing!! :D
I think this is the best potato salad I have ever made! I followed exactly as written and it was perfect. I enjoyed the bacon and cheese, there was just the right amount of dressing, thanks so much for posting