Smoky Thousand Island Dressing

Total Time
Prep 5 mins
Cook 30 mins

Recipe posted by request. Haven't tried it myself.

Ingredients Nutrition


  1. Mix'em up.
  2. Stick it in ye olde icee boxe for a bit to allow flavours to blend.
  3. Store unused portion, refrigerated, in airtight container.
Most Helpful

4 5

First things first: delicious and a huge hit at church social this morning. The salad dressing: Out of relish-used capers for relish, cut hickory smoke down to 1/4 teaspoon, added cracked black pepper and pinch of salt. Added a very small amount of smoked paprika on top. Salad: iceberg, cabbage (didn't have red cabbage only green unfortunately), minced carrots, diced fuji apple, celery, raisins, cucumbers, orange bell, toms, red onion and green onion. The one fault I find is the recipe calls for too much hickory smoke. Other than that, a salad dressing I plan to make again very soon! Best prepared at least one hour in advance. Miller lives on in his recipes!

5 5

I was looking for the perfect dressing for Rueben sandwiches. This is it! Thanks

5 5

Loved this!! Used it for KBlakely's Reuben Meatballs and thought it was an excellent dressing! I kept going back for "tastes" before I actually served dinner!