I've made these numerous times and have always had great results! They turn out soft anf light! I follow the recipe exactly, except add 1 minute to the cooking time.
I am taking off a star from my rating- I had to throw out all but the 3 we ate. They deflated to an awful consistency. I'm sorry- had high hopes for these! These are yummy cookies- but they didn't set for me. I ended up with really big and gloppy cookies- they taste great, and are easy to do, but you need two hands and a washcloth to eat them. Also, I only ended up with 11 cookies. I used everything as stated, except my peanut butter was chunky. Thank you for sharing.
These are the easiest cookies to make and you CANNOT just eat one! Get your milk kiddies...these are YUMMY!