This was easy to make, the finished product looked nice and it tasted good. It just wasn't yummy delicious. The bottom part seemed to be lacking in flavor; the garlicky potatoes mixed in helped a bit. Maybe my family just isn't in to comfort one-dish meals that much--they're more to blame than the recipe!
So good and comforting! DH had a craving...so we chose your recipe and we weren't disappointed. We didn't use corn, but that is just personal preference...we followed the rest of the recipe to a 'T' and it turned out great. We will make this one again. Thanks for sharing!
Absolutely delicious -- my boyfriend and I absolutely loved this! Changes I made: I used canned cream corn, added a can of sweet peas, and used instant mashed potatoes instead of fresh (I did add egg and garlic) because I was crunched for time. Next time I make this (and there definitely will be a next time!), I'll use fresh potatoes. :)
great dish. I didn't cut up the potatoes into cubes because I find that makes the final mash too soggy. Instead, I microwave them for a couple minutes to get the middles cooking, and then transfer them to the pot and boil them whole until a knife slides in and out without sticking.
I make this ecipe all the time. Excellent recipe with a wonderful taste. My husband and I love garlic in rcipes that I make. Thanks Darlene10. This recipe is a keeper.
Very nice easy supper. My kids and hubby gobbled this up! The garlic mashed potatoes were a great addition. I will make this again!
Wow Darlene! This recipe IS pretty much identical! I searched high and low when i lost my recipe and this is pretty close to it,( may actually even be a better recipe!) Like i said, with the exception of the garlic in the potatoes and a few other little details this is pretty darn close, my original i think only called for one can of broth and some water too instead of two cans of broth, so your recipe may be even just that little bit closer! It was the only recipe i used for Shepherd's Pie so i understand when you say you kept coming back to this one!!Thanks for the review and yes, this is a 5!!!!