Really tasty and easy. AND no mess, what more could you ask for? I did mine in the oven and had to increase the cooking time a little. We enjoyed this and I'll certainly make it again.
I also did this in the oven and the time does have to increased to at least an hour. I also used a mandolin to slice the spuds. That way they were all the same size and cooked evenly. Easy to do and very easy to eat!!
This was not a five star recipe. The flavor was just not there. Yes,it was easy to put together and there was no pan to wash but that is all lost it the dish doesn't taste good. There was not one family member that liked this recipe.
After reading all of the excitement this recipe has caused, I decided to go home and try these potatoes last night. Lo and behold, I logged in again this morning to add my review and there has been even more talk! I think that this recipe is wonderful! The potatoes are tasty and my hubby loved them :) I also cooked them in the oven for about an hour.
After working in the yard all day, when dinner time came, I knew hubby was grilling steaks, but hadn't thought about potatoes and remembered this recipe, pulled it up & made it up. I liked that it only takes a few minutes to prepare and have all the ingredients on hand, not needing things you don't use often. Hubby & I liked the taste, texture and seasonings very much,,,and will certainly make this no messy clean-up potatoe dish again! I used the grill method, taking about 45min. I didn't have baking potatoes on hand, so used 4 med. utility potatoes and they were great! I think next time I will leave the skins on,,the recipe didn't say, so to be safe I peeled them but don't think it's necessary. Thanks alot Lorac for sharing!
I love grilled food and with finally some warmer weather decided to bbq. I really liked these potatoes, easy to put together, good flavor. Other family members didn't like as much.
I have this recipe in one of my brand name cookbooks and it has always been a favorite of mine to make grilled potatoes. Everything together gives them good flavor. Just be careful when putting them on the grill. They are easy to burn the bottoms if you have it to hot. I put all my burners on low and alternate them half the time on the bottom rack and the other half on the top. Like someone else had said, its a great idea to open the foil up at the end of cooking so they can get browned on top.
These are delicious! Lots of possible add-ins, too. Thanks for posting. Made for Lorac's Cook-a-Thon and the Cooking Photo Forum Grilling Event.
These potatoes are SOOoooo good. I like that you can get them ready ahead of time (I did mine a couple of hours before cooking) then just pop them on the BBQ or in the oven. I reccommend that you use release foil so the won't stick. I opened up the package 15 mintes before serving so they would brown Thanks Lorac
This just didn't have the favor that was hoped for. I don't know why.