Well, you sure fooled me. I read the recipe and thought "YUK!" I finally decided to try them and as they cooked and I'd peek at them I thought the same thing. When I took them out of the oven I thought they looked like hockey pucks. They smelled good though, so I finally decided to try one. I was surprised, they were quite good. I made one recipe with a Restaurant Ranch dressing and the other with an Italian dressing and both were nice. My husband liked them also. Thanks.