We enjoyed this a lot, though we thought it needed more chocolate sauce to taste like a resse's cup. I doubled it and used frozen bananas for the creaminess. The banana taste was strong at first, which is why I added the extra syrup. Made with skim milk this is a relatively healthy yummy treat. Thanks.
We didn't think that this tasted like a Reese peanut butter cup. It had too much banana flavour which over powered it. I added extra peanut butter and chocolate but still the banana flavour came thru the most. If I make it again I would use only half a banana. Thx for posting though.
This really did taste like a resee's peanut butter cup! Wonderful!
Loved it, Kelsey! I added a frozen banana and I forgot to add the sugar and did not realize it until after I poured it but it was sweet enough for my tastes. I will try anything with peanut butter and chocolate!