Perfect! Loved it wasn't messy with sherbet. It was hard to find red cream soda I found in the smaller 1 liter bottles I think it was Dad's brand which also sells root beer. Thanks everyone enjoyed almost a little to rich might add more 7up next time.
Delicious and refreshing! Couldn't find pink cream soda so we made it with regular cream soda - color was a little funky, but tasted great. This punch was a hit at the baby shower we served it at.
I LOVE this punch! I made it for a baby shower today and the main reason I picked it was because I could put it into my drink dispenser with a spigot and not have to worry about serving out of a punch bowl. Everyone loved it. I couldn't find pink cream soda, so the end result looked a bit like beer :) -Especially with the way it foams when poured. Everyone actually thought it was kind of funny, though. This is my new go-to punch recipe! Thanks for sharing!
I made this without rum for a party. I was a little worried by the fact I could only find original cream soda, not pink, in bottles. However, the final product was a butterscotch color--not too bad! The guests loved it! It tastes a little like a sherbet/ice cream punch without the sherbet (which is why I picked this, needing a punch that would "hold" without melting into a slurry). I made one batch and comfortably served 25.
A really lovely punch. I started by making half of it, but it was so popular, I ended up making the whole recipe. I used the regular color of cream soda, so it wasn't a prett pink color - but it was still very good. Thanks for posting!
This recipe was chosen late last night for use at my New Year's Eve family dinner. I was not certain as to how it would turn out but decided to trust the review. To put it simply, it is delicious. It was a huge hit even with my husband who isn't a fan of any fruity drinks other than orange juice. I was so pleasantly surprised and pleased when I tasted it, and it will be a staple when punch is needed. I added a few ice cubes made of fruit punch and had regular cream soda rather than pink.
This is a great recipe!! I made it last night and added some spiced rum to the mix! It was awesome! I barely got to drink any myself! I will definitly use this again and again, plus I passed it on to some of the Party Goers! I wasn't able to find the cream soda in a pink bottle but the brown worked just as well it just wasn't as pretty!
So easy to make and really good! We all loved it, especially all the kids! We used How to Make an Ice Ring, to make a couple of ice rings to keep it cold outside for the duration of our family barbecue.