Total Time
Prep 15 mins
Cook 30 mins

you can use canned pumpkin if you like the traditional thick texture and sweetness of store-bought pumpkin pie. I like using fresh cooked pumpkin as it's not overly sweet and much lighter and fluffier that way, almost like a mousse. you can freeze cooked pumpkin for many months so you can still make this outside of autumn, just be sure to drain it well when you thaw it. can also be made into a single-crust pie, just increase the cooking time to about an hour. new way to play with this: make just the filling in custard cups or muffin tins and serve with ice cream and butterscotch!

Ingredients Nutrition


  1. pre-cook tart shells for 5-10 at 375 degrees, let cool for a few minutes. someday i need to try this using puff pastry pressed into muffin trays.
  2. while that's cooking dump everything else in the blender and mix on med for 1-2 min until well combined and frothy.
  3. pour liquid filling into tart shells.
  4. bake at 375 for about 30 min or until set but not dry.
Most Helpful

5 5

Very easy and very tasty. I made 2 pies using fresh cooked pumpkin with this crust recipe ( and everyone liked it.

5 5

Absolutely a 5 star recipe! These were so easy to make and they turned out perfectly! I followed the recipe exactly and used just regular milk. Thank you!

5 5

Very Good! I used sweetened, condensed milk instead and they're really tastey! Thank you!