2 Reviews

  • Most Helpful
  • Newest
  • Highest Rating

OMG! So incredibly good! Our fav local burger joint makes awesome milkshakes & makes a pumpkin milkshake I love but hate the price & drive associated with. This recipe UTTERLY replaces Kohls - I halved the recipe & subbed ground ginger (1/2t) for mace. Will be getting mace to repeat. Will also try with sugar-free vanilla ice cream to make it a totally healthy meal - had it for lunch today & am STILL smiling! Thank you Likeitloveit! Will be making this often! Addendum - still making this & loving it! Sweet, creamy & pumpkiny without being fibrous. DH & DF also approve - texture is thick & smooth & sweet enough for our tastes - not looking for "sugar rushes" LOL - maybe previous reviewer did not add milk gradually - I would suggest adding milk until your desired consistency is reached rather than adding all at once.

1 person found this helpful. Was it helpful to you? [Yes] [No]
Buster's friend November 06, 2006

The recipe ingredients must be listed in a very wrong ratio. I put approx. 1/2 of all the ingredients in my blender (for the first "batch") and got a thin, watery concoction. I then added all the remaining ice cream and much of the pumpkin and the result was still too thin for my taste. It also was not sweet enough - the sugar in the ice cream was not nearly enough to compensate for all that unsweetened pumpkin. Perhaps the other reviewer who liked it so much enjoys more of a healthy, smoothy-type drink but I had promised my family a sweet, creamy treat and this was NOT it.

0 people found this helpful. Was it helpful to you? [Yes] [No]
appleydapply October 27, 2006
Pumpkin Nog (Milkshake)