This was good. I wish I had cut the potatoes smaller. I *thought* they were small but they grew. ;) I added an extra cup of water towards the end of cooking because there wasn't much left. DD & I didn't finish it & I added more milk to the leftovers - I like lots of broth. One bit of confusion, the ingredients say 1 onion, the directions say to use 1/4 of the onion. What happens to the rest? I just used it all. Made for PAC Spring '12.