Pina Colada Ice Cream

Total Time
10 mins
40 mins

I enjoy making my own ice cream once in a while using my ice cream machine. The beauty of this homemade recipe is it's all natural ingredients with no preservatives which are usually found in store bought ice cream. I came up with this sweet treat using fresh pineaple and coconut milk. Sweet and refreshing taste of the south!

Skip to Next Recipe




  1. Puree pineaples with food processor.
  2. With mixer, mix together with all remaining ingredients until sugar disolves.
  3. Pour into frozen canister of ice cream machine, mix for approximately 45 minutes.
  4. Freeze for approximately 4 hours.
  5. Serve with fresh pineaple.
Most Helpful

Nice flavour - disappointingly it did not set :(

Great recipe, great texture fresh from the ice cream maker and not too hard after being in the freezer. Taste is smooth and complex, not overwhelming. I used a Cuisinart compressor ice cream maker.

3 5

I love pina coladas and I love ice cream, so I tagged this recipe for New Kids on the Block tag game. Unfortunately, I couldn't get this recipe to work with my tastebuds. I tried true to the recipe and then with my own adaptions and I just couldn't get a good taste. I hope you have better luck as I am sure this could be a wonderful treat for some.