Total Time
Prep 10 mins
Cook 20 mins

The story behind the cookie. This is an old family recipe for me, but I have no idea why they were called one's ever been able to explain that part to me. My aunt, Phyllis, started making them long before I was born. The original recipe called for "Three knives of peanut butter" I've melted it down a couple of times and had about a half a cup, so, there you go. My Mom likes to mix in coconut, but I find that dries them out. Everyone I've ever made them for asks for them over and over, they seem to be addictive. (; Cook time is cooling time.

Ingredients Nutrition


  1. EXCEPT for the oats, mix all ingredients in medium size sauce pan.
  2. Slowly kick up the heat (over four minutes) and bring to rapid boil.
  3. Immidately remove from heat, and stir in oats.
  4. Let cool till mixture will hold its shape and not drip from the spoon. Spoon on to wax paper.
  5. Let cool for about 20 minutes or until they've firmed up. (They never survive that long in my house though.).
Most Helpful

I was craving some chocolaty, peanut buttery and fudgy all in one. This fit the bill! It isn't as fudgy as pure fudge but it's real close. Thanks for sharing this quick and easy recipe. Yes, it is quite sweet but keeps calling you for more.

Roxanne J.R. April 27, 2010

Moxie, this is a great recipe for the kids, next time I will get the grandchildren to help, I think they would love it. I really like when you eat then the chocolate melts and you are left with the oats to have a chew on the peanut comes through real strong a very nice cookie and so easy to make. Thanks for posting. Made for PAC Spring 2010.

Tea Jenny April 23, 2010

These are cooling on the table now... and we are happily picking at them. My 4 yo loved helping scoop the cookies onto the parchment paper. I added extra peanut butter cause I love it, used a touch more cocoa, and used rolled oats, as that's all we have in the house. Might cut back a touch on the sugar next time, as these are VERY sweet, but I love that you can actually taste the peanut butter in these. Thanks for sharing!

Queen Roachie June 01, 2009