- Most Helpful
- Highest Rating
These are very good. The fluff is not something you can really taste but without a doubt they make these cookies SO moist. Not like a lot of peanut butter cookies that sometimes come out dry. My DH could not stop eating them all night. This is my new peanut butter cookie recipe! Thanks
These were very good! My bf said these top all other desserts that I've made thus far. Next time I make them though, I think I'll try them with nuts and see how that turns out. Thanks for the recipe.
These were good, but I prefer a peanut butter cookie to really taste like peanut butter, which these did, just I prefer more of a peanut butter taste. My kids enjoyed them, so they didn't last long.
I love the idea of adding marshmallow fluff to peanut butter cookies, adds a lovely creamy taste! These were very good - wonder if I could up the fluff and maybe consequently use a bit more flour...? Off to experiment! Thank you for a great recipe!
These were good, but not spectacular. I was hoping for a different peanut butter cookie, but these tasted just the same. Also, 15 minutes made them too crunchy for my liking. I will try them again with less peanut butter, and more marshmallow cream, and shorten the baking time. We'll see what happens.
I really didn't like peanut butter cookies until I had these, the marshmallow fluff adds a wonderful taste! I made half a batch in case I didn't like them. I regret it now!!! They're gone!
These cookies were very good. I made the recipe as written, and added the coconut. The cookies were easy to put together and were done baking in 10 minutes. I don't think they were much different or better than a regular peanut butter cookie, although the added coconut was a nice touch. Thanks for sharing your recipe.
my husband LOVES these! the first words out of his mouth was "These are Freeking great!" I did half with coconut and half without. I toasted the coconut too, it added a nice flavor to it. I will make this again maybe add some chocolate chips.