I made these exactly as written and used a bone-shaped cookie cutter. They smelled really good as they baked. My rottweiler, Max, said to definitely give them 5 stars. He couldn't even wait for them to cool off after they came out of the oven. I had a hard time keeping him away from them. The biscuits soft and cakey and Max seems to like them a lot. Made for July 2013 Aus/NZ Swap.