- Most Helpful
- Highest Rating
This cookie is definitely a strong contender to my all time favorite oatmeal molasses cookie -- might even be the winner between the two! : ) Love the addition of the peanut butter and allspice along with the molasses and ginger - lots of wonderful flavors going on in this cookie. They are chewy and satisfying and of course, they will be gone by the end of today if DH has anything to do with it. Placing this recipe in my Best of 2013 Cookbook. Made for PRMR, October 2013.