- Most Helpful
- Highest Rating
This was delicious! Loved the addition of the salad dressings -- I'd have never thought to try that. My 9 year old son loves it too, and has proclaimed that this is the "Best potato salad in the world!" Now, THAT's a compliment... Thanks so much for posting, Pat. Another winner in my house! ~Stacy
We didn't care for this. It kinda tasted like those ready made salads in the deli. I made as directed. To me it just didn't have the homemade taste. Tho hubby and I didn't care for it, our 8 yo ate it up. :-)
This was awesome!!! Everyone that ate it enjoyed it, it was a real hit. The only thing I did different was doubled the sauce, I like mine extra creamy!!! Thanks for sharing:)
Very nice salad! I scaled the recipe down a bit, added a bit mor celery. Thanks Pat!
I made this for a group of thirty for a luncheon-served with ham. Received lots of raves and a request for the recipe. I tripled the recipe but only used one cup of pickle relish. It didn't require much Hellman's. Even people who weren't potato salad eaters really like this. THANKS!!!! -I found the reviews really helpful.
YUM-O!! We have only fusspots in our family when it comes to potato salad. 3 out of 4 raved about it (the other refused to taste it!) I didn't have any Italian dressing, so I just added the ingredients I use when I make my own home-made. Mighty tasty, Bone Man.
I made this twice thinking it would be better the second time but I didn't love this; sorry.
I'm not really a potato salad person so this didn't exactly blow me away. It did have a nice texture and taste though (I adjusted the amounts of some seasonings to suit my tastes).
Absolutely delicious. Thank-You so much Bone Man for posting. Ive been making my own potatoe salad concoction for years now. I'm a little embarrased,lol. I will make this again and again.
I have been wanting to try this for a while and I was not dissapointed, all ingredients blend together well to create a wonderful tater salad, I did make a few amount adjustments and used seasoned salt in place of white, great recipe Pat, thanks for sharing!...Kitten:)