- Most Helpful
- Highest Rating
You've got a winner here! Super-easy to put together, pop in the oven, go do whatever, and Voila!, supper's ready. Love the tender, tasty meat, and the gravy is so yummie. So glad you posted this nifty recipe. Many thanks, Laudee C.
This roast is wonderful and so easy. My family loved it.
Great roast beef recipe, followed the instructions to a T and was rewarded with a delicious non greasy roast meal and with gravy too! Thanks for posting.
This was fantastic! My family loved it and the smell was incredible. I made it in my crockpot on low and used beer instead of water. I also had some finely chopped onions laying around and tossed them in (1/2 cup). After I took out the roast I added some dissolved cornstarch to the sauce in the crockpot to thicken it up. Perfection! Will definitely make again and pass the recipe along.
I was skeptical that something so simple could be as good as the reviews say, but it truly lives up to the hype! The roast was moist and tender, and the gravy was delicious! The first time I made this, I found it a bit too salty, so the second time, I used reduced-sodium cream of mushroom soup, and it was perfect!
This was an excellent dish...the gravy was sooo good. Thank you for a great dinner.
Fabulous! Used dark beer, golden mushroom soup and my own spices (didn't have any onion soup mix in the house) - turned out great. So moist! Thanks so much for my new go-to roast beef recipe!
Very good! I didn't use any soup mix as I made my own gravy afterwards. My boyfriend actually put this together for supper and it turned out great. He's not really kitchen savvy and this was a nice easy recipe for him. He added some onions, carrots and potatoes about an hour before the roast was finished. We will definitely hold on to this recipe. Thanks :)
Amazing! My whole family loved this recipe, even the kids! I will be making this again! Thank you!
My dh & I love sirloin tip roast. We were thrilled with this dish. I have never made roast with soup before and was very pleasently surprised. It was quick and easy to make and it made the house smell great, all afternoon. I used the water option as my dh & I don't drink beer. The roast was moist and tender, the gravy, robust and outstanding. Thanks for sharing your treasure :)