Old Fashioned Potato Salad

READY IN: 20mins
Recipe by Stella Mae

This family favorite has been passed down for several generations. My daughter told me she'd tried all kinds of recipes and had never found one to top this one. I guestimate on quantify, but here are the ingredients. This is not a German potato salad that is largely vinegar. You don't want to detect that the vinegar is even there, yet without it you will not have a superior salad.

Top Review by Happy Hippie

I too inherited this recipe from my mother with minor variation. As the other reviewer noted, I added chopped hard boiled eggs to the mixture and my mom added celery seed as well. She did not add vinegar as there is vinegar in prepared mustard. The only change I myself made is to add a small can of chopped or sliced ripe olives. Any prepared mustard is fine but use the best mayonnaise you can buy, which I believe is Best Foods or Hellmans. That was my mother's rule of thumb as well. This is awesome potato salad loved by all who've eaten it.

Ingredients Nutrition


  1. Boil, peel and dice the potatoes.
  2. Place in large bowl.
  3. Into the bowl, add the rest of the ingredients in whatever amounts you prefer.
  4. Go easy on the vinegar.

Join the Conversation

  • all
  • reviews
  • tweaks
  • q & a