My DH loves this!! I think it's good,too- but he's the banana pudding "fanatic" around here! We love the difference and richness that using Nutter Butters(that's the cookie I used) give. He has requested another batch be made IMMEDIATELY- so thank you so much for sharing!! *A LITTLE NOTE*- After Step 2, wait until the pudding mixture thickens, or the bottom will be soupy.