Being from Long Island as well... I LOVED THIS as did my family on the 4th of July yesterday! There is a "deli" near us that sells NY style but to whip this up at home is much better! THank you!
This recipe was delicious and so easy! My husband even liked it and he is usually a mustard-potato salad guy!
This was good but compared to other potato salads I have had, I prefer the standard potato salad with eggs, onions, celery etc. Nice for a change though!
This is very, very good...next time I will add less vinegar and add some parsley...but close to NY Potato Salad
Excellent recipe. I substituted low fat mayo and added hard boiled egg, finely diced celery, and a bit of finely chopped fresh dill. Yummy and lower in fat!
Well this was great. It sure isn't a potato salad for the weigh conscious people. I am giving 5 stars cuz it would be great as is, but I added green onions and hard boiled eggs. Excellent, and I will make it again :) Made for PAC 09
Add some diced celery and 2 chopped hard boiled eggs and you've got something even better..in my humble opinion.