New York Breakfast Casserole

Total Time
1hr 20mins
Prep 20 mins
Cook 1 hr

Adapted from Deb Perelman's wonderful 'The Smitten Kitchen Cookbook'. Bagels and cream cheese make me reminisce about Collegetown Bagels in Ithaca, New York; I rarely enjoy them now because of the carbs/calories, but found this casserole to be worth it. Gooey on the bottom, crusty on top - yum. The prep and cook times do not include overnight chilling,

Ingredients Nutrition


  1. The night before serving the casserole, spread one half of the bagel cubes in the bottom of a greased 9-by-13-inch pan.
  2. Dot with half of the Neufchatel cheese, and mix in the red onion and tomatoes.
  3. Make one more layer with the bagel cubes and Neufchatel cheese.
  4. Whisk eggs with milk, salt and pepper. Pour mixture over the bagels. Cover pan tightly with plastic wrap and refrigerate overnight.
  5. The next morning, preheat oven to 350 degrees. Remove casserole from the fridge, uncover and bake until casserole has puffed, turned golden brown and cooked through. (A knife inserted into the center of the casserole and rotated slightly should not release any liquid.) This will take about an hour. You may cover the pan with foil for the last 15-20 minutes if the top bagels are getting too brown for your liking.
  6. Let cool a few minutes, and serve in big scoops with a sprinkle of capers and a side of lox or bacon.
Most Helpful

I have a confession to make - I had the SK original recipe, so I'm not sure the review I am writing is for the exact recipe posted here. However ... can I just say it was the most satisfying, delightful and fully gorgeous casserole I've had in ages? I am seriously considering making it for an Easter dinner pot luck just because, dagnabbit, it's that darn good!

Jess M. March 31, 2015

I am giving this a 5 star review based on the flavors and what I feel it would have been if I had used a fresh or day old bagel instead of using a previously frozen, Everything Bagel from Panera Bread which was fresh at the time of freezing, but now feel it wasn't the best way to make this recipe, so my fault. The top part was nice and toasted, and of, course great flavors from the everything toppings, but the bottom layer was very soggy and hard for me to cut through, which I feel would have been different if it had been fresh or a day old bagel. The only changes I made was to scale back the amounts to serve two and I substituted red bell pepper for the tomatoes. I will definitely try this again in the future, as DH often goes out on the weekends and buys fresh bagels. Thanks for sharing the recipe FLKeysJen. Made for PRMR Tag Game.

diner524 January 17, 2014