Miracle Whip from Mayonnaise

Total Time
10mins
Prep 10 mins
Cook 0 mins

I usually use mayonnaise but I have a few recipes that require the extra kick of Miracle Whip. Since I always have mayonnaise on hand, this recipe allows me to make only the required amount of Miracle Whip. I started with the Miracle Whip recipe from Top Secret Recipes. Miracle Whip is more tart than Mayonnaise but adding a vinegar mixture makes the resulting dressing too thin. This recipe solves that problem. I used Hellman's Mayonnaise and I have also made the diet version with Hellman's 1/2 Fat Mayonnaise.(Serving size: 1 tbsp)

Ingredients Nutrition

Directions

  1. Measure vinegar into small non-reactive saucepan. (e.g. Stainless steel or teflon coated).
  2. Add cornstarch and let soften for a minute or so. Stir with non-metal spoon or whisk to remove any lumps.
  3. Add sugar, paprika, garlic and mustard powders.
  4. Heat on medium high, stirring constantly, until mixture reaches a full rolling boil.
  5. Remove from heat, stirring well. The mixture will be the consistency of thin pudding. It will thicken as it cools.
  6. Add to mayonnaise and stir well to combine. Chill for use in a cold salad or use as is in a recipe.
  7. NOTE: To make smaller amounts of Miracle Whip, mix at the ratio 1/2 tsp of additive to 1 tbsp of mayonnaise. Store unused portion of additive tightly covered in the fridge.
  8. If storing additive, discard any film that develops on top as this will never mix properly into the mayonnaise.
  9. Replace sugar with Splenda and/or use Lite Mayonnaise for a diet or diabetic version.

Reviews

(4)
Most Helpful

If using powdered sweetener ( I used stevia) increase to 5 Tbsp. I had a couple of spoonfuls of Miracle Whip left from the last jar I bought on the internet, so could taste test against it, and this was perfect!

Toni B. September 11, 2016

I have a son who is allergic to egg yolks. I've discovered some decent mayonnaise substitutes, but not any miracle whip ones. So THANK YOU for posting this. My entire family approves of this recipe. (Even my miracle whip hating husband.) So, no, it doesn't taste exactly the same. We think it's better.

Sassie Cassie September 11, 2012

I made half the recipe and it really works. It really taste like Miracle Whip. It's just that the color is darker than Miracle Whip. I used it in this recipe : recipe#228777 Thanks Jean :)

Boomette January 24, 2011

Join the Conversation

  • all
  • reviews
  • tweaks
  • q & a