Total Time
4hrs
Prep 1 hr
Cook 3 hrs

This recipe was handed down to me by my mom whom had received this recipe from an Afrikaans lady from the Cape (Cape Town) with whom she nursed with. After being shown the "tricks of the making" this is a flop free recipe.

Ingredients Nutrition

Directions

  1. Crust :.
  2. Cream butter and sugar and add egg. Mix in dry ingredients. Line shells evenly, fluting the edges. Bake until golden brown in colour on 350degrees F / 180degrees Celsius.
  3. Filling:.
  4. Beat eggs, sugar, flour, maizena (cornstarch), salt until smooth. Set to the side.
  5. In a non stick pot, bring the milk to an almost boil(until you see tiny bubbles on the side of the pot (inside). Remove from stove, but don't turn off stove, add egg mixture, stirring in a gentle figure of 8 - put back onto stove, using a whisk continue stirring until mixture starts to thicken - take pot off the stove, then, add butter - whisking gently ensuring all butter is melted, - lastly adding the vanilla essence. Stir in gently.
  6. The shells should still be rather warm when the filling is poured into them. The filling doesn't have to be cooled down prior to filling the shell.
  7. Once shells are filled with the filling, sprinkle liberally with cinnamon.
  8. The left over filling (if there is any) can be enjoyed poured over vanilla ice cream with a sprinkle of cinnamon for a "dessert".
  9. Enjoy!
  10. Please note that the cooking time may vary and this is an approximate "time" for cooking and preparation.

Reviews

(3)
Most Helpful

Tastes just like rice pudding without the rice! The recipe misses a few steps to help you out. (1) I suggest rolling out the dough on wax paper or plastic wrap and transfering it to the pie pan. Otherwise some crust sections can be really thick and dry. (2) When you add the eggs to the boiling milk you have to temper them first or they'll just turn to scrambled eggs. Tempering is really easy, mix the eggs in a separate bowl. Add small amounts of the boiling milk while mixing the eggs in the bowl. This will slowly bring them up to temp. Once the eggs are pretty hot, add slowly to boiling milk in the pan while stirring milk. Works like a charm! (3) When you add the custard you can freeze for about 1 hr or refrigerate overnight. The tart should definitely be kept refrigerated. Enjoy!!

Alicia M. September 13, 2016

My DD made this recipe as her BF is from South Africa and he is always trying to capture the flavors of his childhood. She decided to make the pie into little tarts which she made in a cup cake tin. She baked the dough in the tins for about 10-15 minutes at 350 degrees F. The crust was like a delicious shortbread and the custard was creamy with a hint of vanilla. The cinnamon really enhanced the flavor of both the crust and custard. Thanks for posting!

AcadiaTwo November 29, 2013

it is great and great to have when you have moved away from South Africa

Daniel O'Reilly June 12, 2013

Join the Conversation

  • all
  • reviews
  • tweaks
  • q & a