Mama Mandola's Spicy Sicilian Chicken Soup

Total Time
2hrs 10mins
Prep 10 mins
Cook 2 hrs

From Carrabba's. It has a peppery bite which I love.

Ingredients Nutrition


  1. Dice celery, carrots, onion, potatoes and bell pepper into 1/4-inch pieces.
  2. Chop tomatoes; reserve all juice.
  3. Place vegetables, tomatoes with their juice, chicken pieces, parsley and garlic in a 10-quart stockpot.
  4. Add water. Season with salt and pepper.
  5. Slowly bring soup to a boil over low heat.
  6. Skim off foam that rises to the surface; may have to skim 2 or 3 times.
  7. Partially cover pot and simmer 2 hours.
  8. When soup is finished, remove chicken pieces with a slotted spoon. Let cool.
  9. Meanwhile, mash vegetables in the bottom of the pot with the back side of a large cooking spoon or a potato masher.
  10. When chicken has cooled enough to handle, remove skin and bones and return meat to soup.
  11. Notes: Soup is best served the day after it is made. Refrigerate and remove fat that solidifies on the surface of the soup. Serve soup with rice or small, stubby pasta. For better flavor, cook the rice or pasta in the soup when reheating. Add freshly grated Parmesan or Romano cheese, if desired.
Most Helpful

i used this recipe as a starting point after reading all of the other reviews. Both of my sons have worked at Carrabbas in the past so I asked the manager about this soup recipe. He told me that contrary to what most people think, salt and pepper are the only seasoning in this soup. So, with that in mind, I used onion, celery, carrot, potato, tomatoes, salt and pepper in the stockpot with my chicken. I used no green bell pepper or garlic. I did, however, add just a touch of red pepper, per personal preference. It is amazing. I am going to cook my pasta separately and add to the bowls rather than the whole pot, as that is how it is done at Carrabba's! Hope this is helpful!

5 5

Made the following modifications and it tastes just like the soup at the restaurant to us:

Omit the bell pepper.
Use chicken broth instead of water.
Add about 1.5 tbsp of creole seasoning (don't add salt on top of this, wait and taste it to see if you need more).
Use lots of fresh ground black pepper.
Add 2 tbsp of white wine vinegar (it was definitely missing acid without it).

4 5

The basics are there, but a key ingredient has been omitted. Creole seasoning is used in the actual recipe and no bell peppers are used. I wasn't a cook at Carrabba's, but I did work there for quite some time, so I did know a few of the secrets. :)