Maine Multi-Spice Cookies(Maine Chewies)

READY IN: 42mins
Recipe by HeatherFeather

Adapted from Yankee magazine. Supposedly a version of this recipe is served on board the "Mary Day," a schooner from Maine. Any cookie with cardamom in it is a cookie for me. These are by far the best tasting spice cookies I have ever tried. Please use a wooden spoon to mix the dough - an electric mixer might make the dough too tough.

Top Review by Fuzzy

These cookies are excellent with a cup of coffee!! I did not follow the directions, I put them together as most any other cookie that I cook, mix all dry ingredients including baking powder well, as a retired Merchant Mariner I think that the cook on the schooner “Mary Day” may have been dissolving some old lumpy baking powder. I also added 1 ½ teaspoons of Cream of Tartar to work with the Baking Powder. I followed the ingredients very closely, but I substituted Allspice for Cardamom as I had none on hand and it is hard to come by here in Costa Roca. I added 1 teaspoon of local Cocoa Powder, and used milk instead of water to balance liquids (Next batch I will try coffee!!). Creamed Butter, Sugar, Milk and Egg in stand mixer added blended dry ingredients about 2 cups at a time (tough dough??), and refrigerated the dough a few hours before rolling into balls, baked as usual.I baked ½ as is, and ½ rolled in Azucar Crudo (sort of like a larger crystal sugar in the raw). Personally I prefer the plain ones, I think the extra sugar detracts from the flavors of the spices. However I know a few young cookie monsters that may prefer the sugared ones. Fuzzy

Ingredients Nutrition


  1. Combine butter, sugar, all 5 spices, and salt in a large mixing bowl, mixing well with a wooden spoon.
  2. Dissolve baking soda in the warm water and then stir into the butter mixture.
  3. Stir in the molasses and the lightly beaten egg, mixing well.
  4. Add flour,1 cup at a time, stirring to mix- the dough will be quite stiff (be sure to scrape all the way down to the bottom of the bowl to mix evenly).
  5. Scoop the dough into walnut sized lumps (about 1 Tbsp or so) and drop onto greased or parchment-lined baking sheets, about 2" apart.
  6. Bake in a preheated 350°F oven for 8-12 minutes, or until crackled and browned. They will look very, very soft in the middles but as long as you can lift them with a spatula they are ready.
  7. Let cool 1 minute on pans before carefully lifting with a spatula to cooling racks.
  8. Finished cookies should be somewhat chewy.

Join the Conversation

  • all
  • reviews
  • tweaks
  • q & a