Very tasty cookies although they were much more like an oatmeal cookie than I expected. Next time I think I will add a bit more Kahlua b/c I would have liked the taste to be stronger. All in all, very tasty and different! These are a crispy cookie - FYI. I also had 4 dozen when I was finished. Thanks for a fun recipe!
Fantastic! I only had Reese's Pieces in the house, so used those and they turned out great! I'm not sure if I can taste the Kahlua or not, but they're really good anyway! I made a half recipe and got about 20 cookies.
We could not taste the Kahlua in the cookies but they were pretty good. I wish I had read the reviews before making them. I will take some of the other reviewers suggestion and add more Kahlua next time.
Made these for the holidays and they were enjoyed by all. The Kahula surely adds an extra dimension to the cookies! Loved them. Christina
I made these cookies using kahlua that I made myself. The cookies turned out just right. Thanks for the recipe, KitchenManiac, it's a keeper!!
This recipe with the ground oatmeal is much like the $250 Neiman Marcus cookie. I was hoping the addition of the Kahlua would make them extra special. I halved the recipe as others have stated they got 4 dz cookies using the full amount. Using a cookie scoop (not sure of the size) I still managed to get 38 cookies just using half the ingredients. I also tried using 2 tsp of Kahlua hoping for the flavorful kick but it did not seem to make a difference. Myself and others could not detect the flavor of the Kahlua in the baked product, although it was present in the dough. Good cookie, not great.
The only change I made to this recipe is that I didn't grind up the oatmeal (no time,& I didn't want to fuss with it). It was still a nice texture and very tasty. Next time I will definately add more Kahlua as I couldn't taste it this time. It was a yummy cookie though and we really enjoyed it!
It seems like i am the i only one who go 22 cookies! However i did only make half of the recipe witch is probaly why!Very Very good! I doubles the amount of kahlua and the taste of it is just right! I used m&m's with the peanuts in the middle and they taste great! Thanks for the awsome recipe KitchenManiac!
Great tasting cookie, but like other reviewers, I had about 4 dozen cookies and would definitely add just a tad more kahlua next time.
I seen these cookies and just knew I wanted to try them. WOW! they are good!! I'm making more this christmas to put in cookie tins for gifts. I will be lucky if none gets gone before I get them made and in the tins. LOL DH loves them!!! Thanks for the recipe!