Hubby and i thought this was good. I do wonder if the calorie's posted on this site are right? ANyhoo, i made a couple subsitutions. I used white wine in place of the sherry, and had no mushrooms so i just threw in some thinly sliced celery. The celery really did not do justice, however the recipe was still very good and I would love to make it again with mushrooms. I loved that this recipe did not include canned creamed soups. Thanks for posting.