8 Reviews

  • Most Helpful
  • Newest
  • Highest Rating

I liked your recipe, but i did personal change a few things. I had an 8.5 pound roast, so naturally, i doubled all the ingredients, except the brown sugar. I doubled and added an extra cup of brown sugar. I then added 2 t sp of Lemon pepper and McCormick Barbeque spice. I then cut the Roast into two even pieces and followed your instructions from there. However, i did let marinate for 12 hours. Then i only cooked it the first time at 250 for 4 hours. Then took off tin foil, but left the juice. Cut up onions and carrots and onions and placed in juice, and placed some onions on the top of roasts. I then placed cut green beans and cut broccoli in the juices.Then i poured barbeque sauce on the tops and sprinkled cinnamon and basil leaves on juices and roasts. then i places 4 t sp of butter in juice and 1 t sp of butter on each roast. Then i stirred the juice lightly and put back in oven on 350 for an hour, then i put the roast pan on and left in oven for 30 more mins. This recipe is very amazing and the only thing i did was added my own likings to it. The vegies were amazing too! I really enjoyed the flavorful taste that the roast and vegies had. I hope that you see this and try out my altered recipe as well. Thank you for creating such an amazing taste!

1 person found this helpful. Was it helpful to you? [Yes] [No]
TheQuick15 October 07, 2013

I am not a regular cook, but I was inspired to try something new yesterday and I chose this recipe. It turned out perfect! I did not use the sweet paprika in the rub.(mainly because I could not find it in the store) I took note of Cilantro in Canada's suggestion of keeping the liquid in the pan and added potatoes to the juice when it was time to turn the temperature to 350. My boyfriend does not usually like what I cook, so I rarely do, but he was very impressed with this dish and went back for thirds!

1 person found this helpful. Was it helpful to you? [Yes] [No]
fanta_gal July 23, 2013

I halved the salt and pepper but otherwise followed the recipe. My family loved this. It was moist and so flavourful. Thanks for such a hit in my house.<br/>Update Apr 15, 2013. I have made this recipe many times and my family still loves it. Now instead of draining the liquid from the roast, once I open the foil, I leave it in the pan and place potatoes around the roast and let them cook in the gravy. Oh my, the potatoes are so flavourful. I use the leftover meat on nachos, pizza sandwiches. etc. I have also successfully added some onion pwoder to the rub. A great recipe. Thanks again for posting.

1 person found this helpful. Was it helpful to you? [Yes] [No]
Cilantro in Canada April 15, 2013

I followed the recipe to the letter but the only altration i did is rub that i had done.... that chili powder, garlic, brown sugar and some other spices...... then i let marinate over night with spices on it then i put the brown sugar rub on it and baked it, it turned out really good my family raves all for septs one, he not much on barbcue... 5 out 6 imean that is good so go figure thanks for the recipe it was really good !

1 person found this helpful. Was it helpful to you? [Yes] [No]
Blackwolf10376 October 02, 2012

This is a great recipe. It turned out super tender and my whole family loved it. I followed it precisely- even the Sweet Baby Rays. Total keeper!

1 person found this helpful. Was it helpful to you? [Yes] [No]
Srqchic October 29, 2010

This was awsome! Family of four. Everyone loved it! Slow and low is the way to go!!!

0 people found this helpful. Was it helpful to you? [Yes] [No]
Andy L. July 19, 2014

Great recipe. Stick to it just let the Boston butt marinade in the dry rub over night fully wrapped in aluminum and ready to bake. The next one I do will be on a charcoal grill.

0 people found this helpful. Was it helpful to you? [Yes] [No]
Mike A. January 28, 2014

I added more pepper and garlic,, and used Hickory Smoked Salt and KC Masterpiece Original, and OMG wow! This is super yummy and I'm definitely going to make it again! Worth the wait!!!

0 people found this helpful. Was it helpful to you? [Yes] [No]
KC_hockey_chick December 20, 2010
Low and Slow Boston Butt Pork BBQ ( Oven Method )