Lisa's Wedding Cookie Cake

Be the first to review
READY IN: 10hrs 30mins
Recipe by MarieDanette

This is from It is really yummy. It must be refrigerated to set up- make it the night before you plan to serve it. It could also be made with vanilla pudding using chocolate wafers instead.

Ingredients Nutrition

  • 8 (3 1/2 ounce) packages chocolate pudding mix (can use sugar free, regular instant, or the kind you have to cook, all will work, need to have a 2 c)
  • 10 cups whole milk (or half 'n half if you want to splurge)
  • 2 (1 lb) packages graham crackers


  1. Use a 4 qt bowl.
  2. Line the inside of your bowl with long strips of plastic wrap, leaving enough wrap to fold back over the top when your cake is finished.
  3. Cover the bottom of the bowl with graham crackers, all the way out to the sides. You can break them in half or quarters if you want, but it's also okay just to overlap them.
  4. Make the first two packages of pudding using 2 1/2 cups of milk, not the 4 cups called for in the directions on the box.
  5. Pour approximately a third of the pudding over the layer of graham crackers in your bowl. Gently spread it out with a rubber spatula- doesn't have to be perfectly smooth.
  6. Put another layer of graham crackers on top of the pudding in the bowl.
  7. Put half of the remaining pudding on top of the second layer of grahams. Spread it out so it covers them.
  8. Lay down another layer of grahams and top it with the remaining pudding. Spread out the pudding and lay down another layer of graham crackers. (Don't bother to wash out the bowl, you're just going to make another batch.).
  9. Using another 2 pkgs of pudding and another 2 1/2 cups of milk, make your second batch of pudding.
  10. Use half of the pudding to cover graham crackers. Smooth the pudding with spatula and lay down another layer of grahams, cover with remaining pudding. Top with another layer of grahams.
  11. Make the third batch of pudding using 2 pkgs of pudding and 2 1/2 cups of milk. Put half the pudding on top of your grahams, smooth it out, then put the rest of the pudding on, smooth, and cover with grahams.
  12. Make the final pudding batch using 2 pkgs of pudding and 2 1/2 cups of milk. Put half on the layer of grahams, cover with more crackers, then put the rest of the pudding on, then cover with a double layer of graham crackers.
  13. Fold in the edges of the plastic wrap to cover the contents of your bowl. Find a plate that will fit inside the bowl on top of the cake. Put it in right side up so that it'll push the cake down when it settles. Set a weight on top of the plate. I use a can of fruit.
  14. Refrigerate the cake until time to serve.
  15. When you're ready to serve, remove the weight and the plate, peel back the plastic wrap, and center a serving platter, right side down, over the top of the bowl. Invert the bowl, lift it off, and peel off the plastic wrap.
  16. Frost with sweetened whipped cream.
  17. Slice the cake as you would a pie, in wedge shaped pieces.

Join the Conversation

  • all
  • reviews
  • tweaks
  • q & a